The Commission also considers that the aforementioned wording of Article 8 (1) implies that rules must be laid down which are transparent and regulatory in nature, i.e. having general, and not individual, effect. This, in turn, means that the rules must be published. Only if they are published, will they meet the requirement of transparency since the reasons for, and basis of, current policy on airports will then be clear. Publication would also enable airlines to work out in advance, with a minimum of uncertainty, the airport to which they were likely to be allocated in view of their intended routes, in accordance with the freedom the Community rules sought to confer on carriers.
The fact remains that the French rules by which traffic is allocated within the Paris airport system, and particularly the rules used against Viva Air, have not been published. The Commission therefore concludes that the rules do not apply. What is more, under French law an unpublished regulatory instrument cannot be enforced against persons to whom it purports to apply. Hence, it cannot be used as a basis for an individual decision against such persons.
The fact that the decision to refuse authorization was taken on 28 December 1992, i.e. before the entry into force on 1 January 1993 of Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92, does nothing to alter the foregoing assessment since Article 9 of Council Regulation (EEC) No 2343/90 (5), which was in force prior to Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92, already included similar provisions and since the decision of 28 December 1992 continued to affect the situation after 31 December 1992.
Also, according to the information available to the Commission, as corroborated by the replies set out above which the French authorities provided on 11 March 1993, the latter have pursued a policy for the last 15 years or so - and more particularly the last five years - of promoting the expansion of Paris (CDG) Airport which is to become both the main continental European gateway and a large hub airport. It is a fact that, compared with the situation at other European airports, the physical potential for expanding this one is considerable and that, in March 1993, capacity at Paris (CDG) increased considerably when terminal 2C came into operation.