The Commission is of the opinion that the infringement was intentional or at least negligent.
The parties were well aware, both from the rules of APAG and CEFIC, that their agreement might contravene Article 85. Indeed, one of them had on several occasions openly expressed concern about the need to ensure confidentiality for individual information in the APAG scheme, and yet they deliberately agreed to exchange just that kind of information.
Furthermore the judgment in the Sugar case was well knwon at the time as was the Commission's publicly declared general attitude to these kinds of agreement.