Despite the alleged general nature of the information exchanged it did improve their knowledge of market conditions in a way which strengthened the connection between them so that they would be able to react more rapidly and efficiently to one another's actions.
In view of the market stabilization which the parties undoubtedly wanted to achieve, this inevitably lessened the intensity of competition that would otherwise have existed between them. This is so even if it is accepted that the sales figures first given by Oleofina for 1976-1978 were wrong and had to be corrected because they still provided the others with a parameter for adapting their market behaviour.
Finally, the regular contacts to exchange the sales figures also provided them with a forum for raising criticism if inroads were made into their respective market shares or if the balance of power in the market were to be upset drastically.