Recital 83, Decision_act (EU) 1984/405

In force

The undertakings concerned in this case participated in the anti-competitive agreements and practices either themselves or through dependent subsidiaries or other undertakings controlled by them. In the latter case, the parent companies and subsidiaries or controlled companies are to be regarded as a single economic entity and the parent company is to be held responsible for the actions of its subsidiary.

In the case of the businesses which at the inception of the agreements were independent but were subsequently taken over by Billiton and UM (KZM and Budel in Billiton's case and VM and Asturienne in UM's case), Billiton and UM must be held responsible for the actions of the firms taken over. This is confirmed, for example, by the fact that KZM and Budel's shares of all the costs and distributions arising from the activities of Adena (see point 31) were imputed by the ZPG to Billiton. Hence, Billiton's claim that it was only involved in the ZPG and its agreements from the time it completed its takeover of KZM in 1971 must fail.