The members of the ZPG by and large observed the producer price, although there were outbreaks of discounting, which prompted the ZPG on several occasions to call for greater price discipline from its members (see RTZ cable of 3 June 1966).
From 1975 onwards discounting became more frequent as there was oversupply and the producer price was considerably above that quoted on the LME (MG discussion paper of 31 October 1977). As a result, the discussion paper said, the producer price introduced in 1964 had for the first time lost its stabilizing effect. The minutes of an MG Management Board meeting held on 31 May 1977 felt that the days of the producer price were numbered.
The then UM subsidiary SP, however, thought the producer price should be maintained at all costs (minutes of MG Management Board meeting held on 16 June 1977) and at the MG Board meeting on 12 July 1977 it was expected that the full producer price could be re-established on the market by the end of September 1977. (25) AMSE, too, saw the difficulties in 1977 as stemming from the gap between the LME price and the producer price. In a telex dated 21 July 1977 it recommended that the producer price system should be defended by cessation of discounts and narrowing the gap between the LME and the producer price. The continuation of the producer price system, together with more drastic coordinated production cuts by ZPG members, was also said to be necessary, albeit 'illegal', in a telex sent by AMSE on 4 August 1977.
The collusion over price changes