Recital 73, Decision_act (EU) 1984/405

In force

In their defence, the undertakings concerned in this case have submitted the following argu ments: first, that the agreement of the producer price and the price support measures helped to reduce the often unreasonably high zinc prices on the LME; secondly, that the producer price and the price support measures helped to prevent the violent fluctuations and speculative increases in the LME price and dumping by centrally planned economies; and thirdly, that over a period of years the producer price did not differ markedly from the quoted LME price, and so 'reflected the market', and that the agreements cannot therefore be said to have had any anticompetitive effects.

In reply to these arguments, the first point to be made is that, in attempting to cope with difficult market conditions or extreme falls in demand, firms must use only means which are consistent with competition. The fixing of purchase or selling prices by competitors is not a legitimate means of combating alleged difficult market conditions. Nor are firms entitled to flout the EEC competition rules because of alleged overcapacity. Even the prevention of alleged dumping practices does not justify attempts to regulate prices and markets through private agreements.

The firms' arguments are also unconvincing because action which is really intended to deal with difficult market conditions does not normally last for over a decade. In addition, for a long period the agreed producer price was higher than the LME price. The LME price in any case cannot be accepted as a gauge of how truly the producer price reflected a market price, since the LME price too was influenced by the firms. Owing to the action of the ZPG members, only marginal quantities of zinc and an unrepresentative range of qualities were traded on the LME.