1.1. Member States shall establish reference buildings for the following building categories:
single-family buildings;
apartment blocks and multifamily buildings;
office buildings.
1.2. In addition to office buildings, Member States shall establish reference buildings for other non-residential building categories listed in paragraph (6)(d) to (i) of Annex I to Directive (EU) 2024/1275 for which specific energy performance requirements exist.
1.3. If a Member State is able to demonstrate in the report referred to in Article 6 of this Regulation that an established reference building can be applicable to more than one building category, it may reduce the number of reference buildings used and with that the number of calculations. Member States shall justify this approach on the basis of an analysis showing that a reference building that is used to serve several building categories is representative of the building stock for all the categories covered.
1.4. For each building category, at least one reference building shall be established for new buildings and at least two for existing buildings subject to major renovation. Reference buildings can be established on the basis of building subcategories (e.g. differentiated by size, age, cost structure, construction material, use pattern or climatic zone) that take into account the characteristics of the national building stock. Reference buildings and their characteristics shall correspond to the structure of current or planned energy performance requirements.
1.5. Member States shall make use of the reporting template provided in Annex III to report to the Commission the parameters considered in establishing the reference buildings. The underlying dataset on the national building stock used for establishing the reference buildings shall be communicated to the Commission as part of the report referred to in Article 6. In particular the choice of characteristics that underpin the establishment of reference buildings shall be justified.
1.6. For existing buildings (both residential and non-residential), Member States shall apply at least one measure/package/variant representing a standard renovation necessary to maintain the building/building unit (without additional energy efficiency measures beyond legal requirements).
1.7. For new buildings (both residential and non-residential), the currently applicable minimum energy performance requirements shall constitute the basic requirement to be met.
1.8. Member States shall calculate cost-optimal levels also for minimum performance requirements for building elements installed in existing buildings or derive them from the calculations done at buildings level. When setting requirements for building elements installed in existing buildings, the cost-optimal requirements should to the extent possible take into account the interaction of that building element with the entire reference building and other building elements.
1.9. Member States shall calculate and set cost-optimal requirements at the level of individual technical building systems for new and existing buildings or derive these from the calculations done at buildings level not only for heating, cooling, hot water, air-conditioning and ventilation (or a combination of such systems), but also for lighting systems for non-residential buildings.
1.10. If a Member State opts to take the life-cycle global warming potential (GWP) into account for the calculation of the cost-optimal levels, parameters that go beyond the operational energy and emission performance of the reference building and that have an impact on its whole life-cycle GWP, shall also be taken into consideration as part of the measures/packages/variants.
2.1. Energy efficiency measures for both new and existing buildings shall be defined for all input parameters for the calculation that have a direct or indirect impact on the energy performance of the building.
2.2. Measures may be bundled into packages of measures or variants. If certain measures are not suitable in a local, economic or climatic context, Member States should indicate this in their reporting to the Commission in accordance with Article 6 of this Regulation.
2.3. Member States shall also identify measures/packages/variants using renewable energy for both new and existing buildings. Binding obligations laid down in the national legislation transposing Article 15a of Directive (EU) 2018/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council [Directive (EU) 2018/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 December 2018 on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources (OJ L 328, 21.12.2018, p. 82, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/dir/2018/2001/oj).] shall be considered as one measure/package/variant to be applied in that Member State.
2.4. Energy efficiency measures/packages/variants identified for the calculation of cost-optimal requirements shall include measures necessary to meet the currently applicable minimum energy performance requirements. If applicable, they shall also include measures/packages/variants necessary to meet the requirements of national support schemes. Member States shall also include measures/packages/variants necessary to meet the minimum energy performance requirements for zero-emission buildings for new and possibly also existing buildings as defined by Article 11 of Directive (EU) 2024/1275.
2.5. If a Member State can demonstrate, by submitting previous cost analyses as part of the reporting referred to in Article 6, that certain measures/packages/variants are far from cost-optimal, these may be excluded from the calculation. However, such measures/packages/variants should be revisited in the subsequent review of the calculations.
2.6. The selected energy efficiency measures and measures based on renewable energy sources, and packages/variants, shall be compatible with the basic requirements for construction works as listed in Annex I to Regulation (EU) 2024/3110 and specified by Member States and the predetermined environmental essential characteristics listed in Annex II to that Regulation. They shall also be compatible with levels of indoor environmental quality (IEQ), as defined in Article 2(66) of Directive (EU) 2024/1275. IEQ requirements introduced in Articles 7(6), 8(3), and 13(5) shall be considered. In cases where measures produce different comfort levels, this shall be made transparent in the calculations.
3.1. Energy performance is calculated in accordance with the common general framework provided in Annex I to Directive (EU) 2024/1275.
3.2. Member States shall calculate the energy performance of measures/packages/variants by calculating, for the nationally defined reference floor area, first the energy needed for heating and cooling. Subsequently the delivered energy for space heating, cooling, ventilation, domestic hot water and lighting systems is calculated.
3.3. Renewable energy produced and self-used on site for EPB services shall not be accounted in the total primary energy use. Renewable energy produced on site and used on site for non-EPB uses or exported to the grid may be deducted from the primary energy use. On-site renewable energy production shall be calculated by using sub-hourly, hourly or monthly modelling adjusted e.g. through considering monthly correction factors.
3.4. Member States shall calculate the resulting total primary energy use using renewable and non-renewable primary energy conversion factors or weighting factors per energy carrier established at national level, pursuant to Annex I to Directive (EU) 2024/1275. They shall report to the Commission the primary energy conversion factors or weighting factors in the reporting referred to in Article 6 of this Regulation.
3.5. Member States shall use:
either the relevant existing CEN standards for the calculation of energy performance;
an equivalent national calculation method provided that it complies with Article 2(8) of and Annex I to Directive (EU) 2024/1275.
3.6. For the purpose of the cost-optimal calculation, energy performance results shall be expressed in square metres of reference floor area of a reference building and refer to, at least, total primary energy use.
3.7. Member States shall also calculate the emission performance using emissions factors established at national, regional, and/or local level. The emission performance, in this context, refers to the operational emissions. Member States may take into account the life-cycle GWP and, for that purpose, they may use a calculation methodology pursuant to Annex III to Directive (EU) 2024/1275, designed for the calculation of the GWP of new buildings.
3.8. In the calculation, Member States may take into account future changes of outdoor climate conditions according to best available climate projections, including heat and cold waves. To do this, Member States may refer to the data on heating degree days and cooling degree days, published annually by Eurostat to build their national projections, or refer to the projections prepared by the Commission and referred to Annex II. Other relevant sources can be used, provided that they are sufficiently documented and reported to the Commission.
Member States shall establish and describe the following separate cost categories to be used, noting that for the calculation at macroeconomic level applicable charges and taxes are to be excluded:
Initial investment costs.
Annual costs. In addition, these might include the earnings from energy produced that Member States may, if appropriate, take into account in the financial calculation.
Waste management costs, if appropriate.
For the calculation at macroeconomic level, Member States shall also establish the following cost categories:
Cost of greenhouse gas emissions. These shall reflect the quantified, monetised and discounted operational costs of CO2 resulting from the greenhouse gas emissions in tonnes of CO2 equivalent over the calculation period. If a Member State opts to take into account the life-cycle GWP for the calculation of the cost-optimal levels, indicating the building’s overall contribution over its whole life cycle to emissions that lead to climate change, the cost of greenhouse gas emissions may be expanded to include it.
Cost of environmental and health externalities of energy use. These shall reflect the quantified and monetised operational costs of air pollutants related to energy use (namely, at least PM2,5 and NOx).
In projecting energy cost developments, Member States may use the energy price development referred to in Annex II to this Regulation for oil, gas, and coal, starting with the average absolute energy prices (expressed in euro) for these energy sources in the year of the calculation exercise.
Member States shall also establish national energy price development forecasts for other energy carriers used to a significant extent in their regional/local context and if appropriate also for peak load tariffs. They shall report the projected price trends and the current shares of the different energy carriers in building energy use to the Commission.
The effect of (expected) future price developments for costs other than energy costs, the replacement of building elements during the calculation period, and waste management costs where applicable, may also be included in the cost calculation. Price developments, including through innovation and adaptation of technologies, have to be taken into account when the calculations are reviewed and updated. To this end, Member States may use the technology cost assumptions referred to Annex II to this Regulation.
Cost data for cost categories (a) to (c) shall be market-based and shall be coherent as regards location and time. Costs should be expressed as real costs excluding inflation. Costs shall be assessed at country level.
When determining the global cost of a measure/package/variant, the following may be omitted:
costs that are the same for all assessed measures/packages/variants;
costs related to building elements which have no influence on the energy and, where relevant, emission performance of a building.
All other costs need to be fully taken into account for the calculation of global costs.
The residual value shall be determined by a straight-line depreciation of the initial investment or replacement cost of a given building element until the end of the calculation period discounted to the beginning of the calculation period. The depreciation time is determined by the economic lifetime of a building or building element. Residual values of building elements may need to be corrected for the cost of removing them from the building at the end of the estimated economic life cycle of the building.
Waste management costs, if applicable, are to be discounted and can be subtracted to the final value. They might need to be first discounted back from the estimated economic lifetime to the end of the calculation period and in a second step discounted back to the beginning of the calculation period.
At the end of the calculation period, the waste management costs (if applicable) or the residual value of the components and building elements are taken into account to determine the final costs over the estimated economic lifecycle of the building.
Member States shall use a calculation period of at least 30 years for residential and public buildings, and a calculation period of at least 20 years for commercial, non-residential buildings.
Member States are encouraged to use Annex D to EN 15459-1 on economic data for building elements when defining estimated economic lifetimes for those building elements. If other estimated economic lifetimes for building elements are established, these should be reported to the Commission as part of the reporting referred to in Article 6. Member States shall define at national level the estimated economic lifecycle of a building.
When determining the global cost of a measure/package/variant for the financial calculation, the relevant prices to be taken into account are the prices paid by the customer including all applicable taxes including VAT and charges. Ideally also the subsidies available for different variants/packages/measures are to be included into the calculation, but Member States can choose to leave subsidies aside, ensuring however that in that case both subsidies and support schemes for technologies but also possibly existing subsidies for energy prices are taken out.
Global costs for buildings and building elements shall be calculated by summing the different types of costs and applying to these the discount rate by means of a discount factor so as to express them in terms of value in the starting year, plus the discounted residual value as follows:
CgτCI +
j
τ
i
Ca,ij × Rdi – Vf,τj
where:
τmeans the calculation period
Cg (τ)means global cost (referred to starting year τ 0) over the calculation period
CImeans initial investment costs for measure or set of measures j
Ca,i(j)means annual cost during year i for measure or set of measures j
Vf,τ(j)means residual value of measure or set of measures j at the end of the calculation period (discounted to the starting year τ 0)
Rd (i)means discount factor for year i based on discount rate r to be calculated
as:
Rdp11 +
r
100p
where p means the number of years from the starting period and r means the real discount rate.
Member States shall determine the discount rate to be used in the financial calculation after having performed a sensitivity analysis on at least two different rates of their choice.
When determining the global cost for the macroeconomic calculation of a measure/package/variant, the relevant prices to be taken into account are the prices excluding all applicable taxes, VAT, charges and subsidies.
When determining the global cost at macroeconomic level of a measure/package/variant, in addition to the cost categories listed under 4.1, points (a) to (c), other cost categories are included so that the adjusted global cost methodology reads as:
CgτCI +
j
τ
i
Ca,ij + Ca,EN,ij × Rdi + CC,ij – Vf,τj
where:
Ca,EN,i (j)means annual cost of the environmental and health externalities of energy use for measure or set of measures j during year i
CC,i (j)means carbon cost for measure or set of measures j during year i.
Member States shall calculate the cumulated carbon cost of measures/packages/variants over the calculation period by taking the sum of the annual greenhouse gas emissions multiplied by the expected prices per tonne CO2 equivalent of greenhouse gas emission allowances in every year issued, and are recommended to use the most recent carbon price trajectories provided by the Commission as recommended key parameter for national GHG projections (as referred to Annex II).
To calculate the annual cost of the environmental and health externalities of energy use for measures/packages/variants, Member States shall multiply the corresponding annual pollutant emissions by the respective price per tonne. The pollutants to be considered in this calculation are at least fine particulate matter (PM2,5) and nitrogen oxides (NOx). For the cost calculation, Member States are recommended to use as reference the values referred to in Annex II and may also decide to include in the calculation the other relevant air pollutants mentioned in Article 1 of Directive (EU) 2016/2284: sulfur dioxide (SO2) and non-methane volatile organic compounds (NMVOC). For the calculation of the environmental and health externalities of energy use, reference values in terms of pollutant emission of different energy sources (g/kWh of fuel) can be found in the EMEP/EEA air pollutant emission inventory guidebook and the related emission factor database.
Member States shall determine the discount rate to be used in the macroeconomic calculation after having performed a sensitivity analysis on at least two different rates, one of which shall be 3 % in real terms.
The purpose of a sensitivity analysis is to identify the most important parameters of a cost-optimal calculation. Member States shall perform a sensitivity analysis on the discount rates using at least two discount rates each expressed in real terms for the macroeconomic calculation and two discount rates for the financial calculation. One of the discount rates to be used for the sensitivity analysis for the macroeconomic calculation shall be 3 % in real terms. Member States shall perform a sensitivity analysis on the energy price development scenarios for all energy carriers used to a significant extent in buildings in their national context. It is recommended to extend the sensitivity analysis also to other crucial input data, including, for example, future technology prices, primary energy factors and weighting factors, emission factors.
6.1. For each reference building, Member States shall compare the global cost results calculated for different energy efficiency measures and measures based on renewable energy sources and packages/variants of those measures.
6.2. In cases where the outcome of the cost-optimal calculations gives the same global cost range for different levels of energy performance, Member States are encouraged to use the requirements resulting in lower use of total primary energy as the basis for comparison with the existing minimum energy performance requirements. Member States are also encouraged to use the requirements minimising the energy needs of the building.
6.3. Once a decision is taken on whether the macroeconomic or the financial calculation is to become the national benchmark, averages of the calculated cost-optimal energy performance levels for all the reference buildings used, taken together, shall be calculated in order to compare them with the averages of the existing energy performance requirements for the same reference buildings. This is to allow the calculation of the gap between existing energy performance requirements and the calculated cost-optimal levels.