51 5. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS AND HEARINGS › 5.8. Conclusion, Regulation (EU) 2024/738

In forcesince 1 Mar 2024

To conclude, the Commission was concerned that CCCMC omitted to consult the Commission while it was approached by the new exporter with the new undertaking offer. That behaviour constitutes a violation of the undertaking and, therefore, the undertaking must be withdrawn. CCCMC is not entitled to solely, without any consultation with the Commission, conclude what is the practice of the Commission, especially as regards the exceptional form of measures like undertakings, which have to be assessed on case-by-case manner. Neither CCCMC nor the exporters concerned managed to present any previous example of the acceptance of the undertaking for the new exporter in the same circumstances as in the new exporter review in citric acid, and any other similar case or alleged previous Commission’s practice would not impinge upon the Commission’s discretion to terminate undertakings in the circumstances of the present case. Similarly, the argument put forward by the parties that the withdrawal of the undertaking is not in the interest of the Union is not relevant in this case. According to Article 8 of the basic Regulation, Union interest is not an element for assessing the practicality and effectiveness of an undertaking offer. In any case, parties have not presented any substantiated argument about the negative impact of the undertaking’s withdrawal for the Union industry or the Union market. Lastly, the Commission has not been presented any new solution that could be practical for monitoring.