As regards the allegation on unequal treatment and discrimination, it must be stressed that only parties to the undertaking whose offers were accepted are entitled to possess the information about the MIP, not all exporting producers of the product concerned. Seven Star, although subject to the measures in the form of duties, has never been accepted as a party of the undertaking. In the new exporter review the undertaking offer submitted by Seven Star was not accepted due to other reasons, namely, it was inconsistent with its specific situation resulting from the investigation. This confirms that each case should be assessed separately according to the circumstances. It must be underlined that it is not the exporting producer or CCCMC who may decide who is or not entitled to the MIP. It is in the discretion of the Commission to accept or not the undertaking offer based on the criteria stipulated in Article 8 of the basic Regulation. Furthermore, Seven Star was not required to submit an offer with a calculation mechanism for the MIP identical with the three undertaking offers already accepted. Rather, Seven Star should have proposed an approach for the determination of the MIP and its future indexation, including the calculation components and benchmarks to be used, taking into account the specific circumstances of this company. Seven Star used the same MIP methodology as for other exporting producers, which was not appropriate for it, causing that its offer could not be accepted. Therefore, any allegation regarding discrimination or non-equal treatment are groundless.
34 5. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS AND HEARINGS › 5.1. CCCMC behaviour as a breach of undertaking, Regulation (EU) 2024/738
In forcesince 1 Mar 2024