CCCMC and the exporters concerned alleged that the withdrawal of the undertakings is too oppressive and non-proportional to the behaviour of CCCMC and other exporters. It must be noted that the Commission enjoys the discretion to assess the behaviour of the parties for the purpose of defining the nature of the undertaking infringed and determining whether it is necessary to withdraw the acceptance of the undertaking. As already explained above, the Commission found an infringement of the undertaking by CCCMC, and a breach of the relationship based on trust. Furthermore, the Commission found that in these circumstances the undertaking and its monitoring is no longer practical, which itself is an independent reason to withdraw the undertaking. It must also be recalled that undertakings may be withdrawn regardless of the level of the materiality of the breach. Moreover, the undertaking offers were accepted due to the role of CCCMC in the implementation and monitoring of the undertaking, which also was stressed by CCCMC itself in the written submission and hearing. Therefore, in case of breach of trust between the Commission and CCCMC, which is a joint party of each exporter’s undertaking, the breach of trust is implied for all exporters. Thus, after thorough analysis, the Commission concluded that the acceptance of the undertakings shall be withdrawn.
48 5. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS AND HEARINGS › 5.6. Proportionality, Regulation (EU) 2024/738
In forcesince 1 Mar 2024