Following the final disclosure, Özkan Demir reiterated its claim that the Commission did not meet the burden of proof for making an adjustment and did not demonstrate the impact of the variation of exchange rate on prices and price comparability. The Commission first noted that the adjustment foreseen by Article 2(10)(j) of the basic Regulation is currency conversion that enables a dumping calculation where values for costs and prices in various currencies must be compared. Özkan Demir does not contest the need for this adjustment. Within this adjustment the Commission is to choose a date for a conversion rate. According to Article 2(10)(j), ‘purchase order or order confirmation may be used if those more appropriately establish the material terms of sale’. As explained above and in recital (138) of the provisional Regulation, in this particular case, the purchase order more appropriately establishes the material terms of sale. Özkan Demir failed to rebut this fact in their comments on the final disclosure. Indeed, the Commission noted that during the investigation period the devaluation of the Turkish Lira as compared to the Euro was of around 74 %. The Commission also noted that the time lag between the order date and the invoice date varied greatly: between 0 days and 266 days for domestic sales and between 20 days and 219 days for sales to the EU. This means that, had the exchange rate of the date of the invoice been used, the material terms of sales (such as prices) set at the time of the purchase order would have been distorted by a significant difference in the exchange rate that occurred between that date and the date of the invoice due to the devaluation of the Turkish Lira. The Commission also noted that Özkan Demir was using foreign currencies for its domestic and export sales which shows that it anticipated strong variations in the valuation of its domestic currency compared to foreign currencies. Therefore, the company itself was mitigating the effects of the devaluation on the price agreed at the moment of the purchase order and the income that agreed price could secure when invoiced. In other words, Özkan Demir itself used currency-based mechanisms to prevent the distortion of prices agreed in purchase orders by the devaluation of the Turkish domestic currency.
66 3. DUMPING › 3.2. Türkiye › 3.2.3. Comparison, Regulation (EU) 2024/209
In forcesince 10 Jan 2024