55 3. DUMPING › 3.2. Türkiye › 3.2.1. Normal value, Regulation (EU) 2024/209

In forcesince 10 Jan 2024

In this regard and when considering relevant adopted WTO jurisprudence, the Commission recalled that the Panel in EC – Salmon (Norway) specifically acknowledged that ‘a finding of sales made at prices above weighted average cost for the period of investigation would be sufficient to show that all sales not found to be above weighted average cost for the period of investigation do not provide for the recovery of costs within a reasonable period of time’ [DS337: European Communities – Anti-Dumping Measure on Farmed Salmon from Norway, para. 7.275.]. The panel also discussed the meaning of the terms ‘at the time of sale’ and noted in paragraph 7.243 that ‘Article 2.2.1 [of the Anti-Dumping Agreement] does not explain what is meant by “prices which are below per unit costs at the time of sale”. In this regard, we see a similarity between the first and second sentences of Article 2.2.1. Although both sentences envisage a calculation of per unit costs over a period of time, neither specifies exactly what this period of time should be. It is true that the second sentence goes further than the first sentence in that it contemplates an assessment of costs at the “time of sale”. However, in our view this means only that the relevant time-period must include “the time of sale”. Thus, it would be entirely consistent with the second sentence of Article 2.2.1 for an investigating authority to calculate per unit costs at the “time of sale” over the particular day of sale, or an average including that day, over a week, month or the period of investigation.’ The panel further elaborated on its reasoning in footnote 417 where it stated that ‘In this regard, we find it significant that whereas the drafters of the AD Agreement used the words “date of sale” in Article 2.4.1, they chose to use “time of sale” in the second sentence of Article 2.2.1. In our view, this difference supports the view that the “time of sale” that is referred to in the second sentence of Article 2.2.1 does not necessarily have to be the “date of sale”, and may include other “time” periods.’