47 3. DUMPING › 3.2. Türkiye › 3.2.1. Normal value, Regulation (EU) 2024/209

In forcesince 10 Jan 2024

Following the final disclosure, Özkan Demir claimed that preferring a yearly calculation, to a quarterly calculation, in the absence of production in at most a third of the relevant period was without merit as the absence of production in given months remains. As mentioned in recital (46), the Commission considered that the use of a yearly average cost of production allows the reflection of the relevant costs throughout the whole year thereby diminishing the impact related to the absence of production in given periods. In other words, an average for a year, even if cost data for some months throughout that year were missing, more accurately reflects the costs of production in the period it covers. Özkan Demir provided no evidence to the contrary. This is clearly not the case for an average for a quarter where there is no cost data for the entire third of that quarter. Therefore, for the quarters where the third of the costs of production data was missing, the average costs of production were not considered by the Commission as representative of the period they were meant to cover. In their comments on the final disclosure Özkan Demir provided no arguments or solutions that would address this obvious deficiency of the quarterly method in this particular case. Furthermore, the Commission noted that, for several product types, there was a mismatch between the quarters where certain models were manufactured and the quarters when they were sold on the domestic market. Therefore, if the quarterly approach was adopted, for those product types it would not be possible to conduct an ordinary course of trade test under Article 2(4) of the basic Regulation. This is because for some of the quarters where sales occurred there would be no cost data at all. In other words, the quarterly approach would not only lead to unrepresentative values when considered generally, but, for specific product types, it would not allow a comparison of the price applicable in that quarter with corresponding costs in the same quarter. On this basis, it was confirmed that the use of a yearly average cost of production for each model would allow the reflection of the relevant costs throughout the whole year and be an appropriate basis for a yearly dumping calculation. The claim was therefore rejected.