ANNEX VI ACCEPTANCE METHODOLOGY, Decision_act (EU) 2024/365

In forcesince 23 Jan 2024

1.1. Section 2 shall not apply to a relevant chemical species which is a starting substance, or an organic cementitious constituent, or a substance constituent or a non-intentionally added species where such substance or constituent is:

(a)

classified as (i) Category 1A or 1B for carcinogenicity, mutagenicity or reproductive toxicity; (ii) Category 1 for endocrine disruption for human health; (iii) persistent bioaccumulative and toxic; (iv) very persistent and very toxic; (v) persistent mobile and toxic; or (vi) very persistent and very mobile under Regulation (EC) No 1272/2008; or

(b)

identified as a substance of very high concern under the Candidate List established under Article 59 of Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006, except those identified on the basis of Article 57(f) of Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 only for the environment.

In either case, the starting substances or organic cementitious constituents referred to in the first paragraph shall be accepted in the European positive list under the following conditions of use:

(a)

The relevant chemical species is:

(i)

a non-intentionally added species, or

(ii)

substance constituent, or

(iii)

starting substance or organic cementitious constituent which is monomer of a main polymer of the contact material.

(b)

Ctap is lower than the generic limit of 0,1 μg/l or the relevant MTCtap calculated from a parametric value set under Annex I to Directive (EU) 2020/2184 by application of an appropriate allocation factor (ALF) to take into account multiple routes of exposure to the relevant chemical species, besides exposure via materials used in products in contact with water intended for human consumption;

(c)

The concentration of the starting substance, organic cementitious constituent, substance constituent or non-intentionally added species in the final material is lower than 0,1 % (weight/weight), except if physical migration testing is uncertain in which case the concentration in the final material is lower than 0,02 % (weight/weight).

1.2. Part 2.4 of Section 2 shall not apply in the case of any concern that a relevant chemical species which is a starting substance, or an organic cementitious constituent, or a substance constituent, or a non-intentionally added species may have genotoxicity, carcinogenicity or endocrine disruption properties for human health with non-threshold mode of action.

In such case, the starting substances or organic cementitious constituents referred to in the first paragraph may be accepted in the European positive list if Ctap is lower than a generic limit of 0,1 μg/l or the relevant MTCtap value calculated from a parametric value set under Annex I to Directive (EU) 2020/2184 by application of an appropriate ALF to take into account multiple routes of exposure to the relevant chemical species, besides exposure via material used in products in contact with water intended for human consumption.

1.3. Part 2 of Section 2 shall not apply to a relevant chemical species in any of the following cases:

(a)

a parametric value for the relevant chemical species in the applicable material type is set under Annex I to Directive (EU) 2020/2184, in which case the MTCtap value shall be calculated by application of an appropriate ALF to take into account multiple routes of exposure to the relevant chemical species, besides exposure via material used in products in contact with water intended for human consumption, in which case that MTCtap value shall be used for the purpose of Part 4 of Section 2;

(b)

a MTCtap value for the relevant chemical species in the applicable material type is set under the corresponding Annex of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/367 following a decision by the Commission on an application for a starting substance, composition or organic cementitious constituent that has been submitted to ECHA under Article 4 of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2024/369, in which case that MTCtap value may be used for the purpose of Part 4 of Section 2 provided that it may not be impacted by information not included in the previous application for the concerned starting substance, composition or organic cementitious constituent;

(c)

an authorisation for an active substance has been granted under Regulation (EU) No 528/2012 on the basis of an ECHA opinion setting a defined safety threshold for the oral route and used as such in material in contact with water under product-type 6, in which case that safety threshold shall be used for the purpose of Part 4 of Section 2;

(d)

a specific migration limit has been set under Commission Regulation (EU) No 10/2011 in less than 15 years from the date of submission of the application under Article 4 of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2024/369, in which case that specific migration limit divided by 20 l/kg shall be used for the purpose of Part 4 of Section 2.

1.4. Part 2.4 of Section 2 shall not apply in the following cases:

(a)

the available information for the relevant chemical species is insufficient to exclude genotoxicity, in which case the generic limit MTCtap of 0,1 μg/l shall apply for the purpose of Part 4 of Section 2;

(b)

the available information set out in Tables 1, 2 and 3 of Annex V for the relevant chemical species is sufficient to exclude genotoxicity but does not allow to conclude on toxic effects listed under Part 2.1.2 of Section 2. In such case the generic limit MTCtap of 2,5 μg/l shall apply for the purpose of Part 4 of Section 2. Such generic limit cannot be applied for the toxic effects for human health with non-threshold mode of action referred to in the first paragraph of Section 1.2.

1.1. The acceptance methodology for starting substances, compositions and constituents shall be based on a risk assessment. Such risk assessment shall result in:

(a)

determining the maximum tolerable concentration at tap water (MTCtap) for each relevant chemical species;

(b)

ensuring that Ctap for each relevant chemical species is lower than its MTCtap.

1.2. In addition to the information required under Annexes I, II and III, a risk assessment shall take into account any other relevant technical or scientific information which is available addressing worst foreseeable conditions of use. Where appropriate, conditions of use shall be implemented.

1.3. The information provided in the risk assessment shall allow the Committee for Risk Assessment of ECHA to evaluate and reach an opinion on whether the starting substance, composition or constituent complies with the criteria set out under Article 11(1) of Directive (EU) 2020/2184.

2.1. Principles

2.1.1. For accepting a starting substance, composition or constituent, the hazard assessment process, in relation to human health shall entail assessment of effects, comprising the following steps:

(a)

hazard identification: identification of the adverse effects which the relevant chemical species have an inherent capacity to cause;

(b)

hazard characterisation: dose (concentration) – response (effects) assessment: estimation of the relationship between dose, or level of exposure to the relevant chemical species, and the incidence and severity of an effect, where appropriate.

2.1.2. The hazard assessment for human health shall address the following potential toxic effects for the general human population and exposure by the oral route:

(a)

mutagenicity;

(b)

systemic (target-organ) toxicity after repeated dose administration;

(c)

toxicity for reproduction;

(d)

carcinogenicity;

(e)

neurotoxicity;

(f)

immunotoxicity;

(g)

endocrine disruption for human health.

2.1.3. The hazard identification shall address the properties and potential adverse effects of the relevant chemical species that migrate from the material.

2.2. Dose-response assessment

2.2.1. The establishment of a quantitative dose (concentration)-response (effect) relationship is required and, where possible, a no observed adverse effect level (NOAEL) shall be identified. If it is not possible to identify a NOAEL, the lowest observed adverse effect level (LOAEL) shall be identified. Where appropriate, other dose-effect descriptors may be used as reference values.

2.2.2. When carrying out the hazard assessment, special consideration shall be given to toxicity data derived from observations of human exposure where such data are available, e.g. information gained from manufacture, from poison centres or epidemiology surveys.

2.3. Derived no effect level

2.3.1. The derivation of a derived no effect level (DNEL) shall be carried out in accordance with Section 1.4 of Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006.

2.4. Maximum Tolerable Concentration at the tap (MTCtap)

2.4.1. Subject to Part 2.4.2, the MTCtap is equal to a value calculated on the basis of the safe oral dose (DNEL), the body weight (60 kg), the drinking water ingestion rate of 2 l (litres) per day and an appropriate ALF (expressed as a percentage) to take into account multiple routes of exposure to the relevant chemical species, besides exposure via material used in products in contact with water intended for human consumption.

MTCtap (μg/l) = DNEL mgkgd60 kg1 000 μgmg2 ld ALF

2.4.2. By way of exception to Part 2.4.1:

(a)

If the Ctap < 2,5 μg/l and genotoxicity tests are negative: MTCtap shall (1) not be lower than 0,1 μg/l for an organic cementitious constituent; and (2) not be higher than 2,5 μg/l, unless duly justified and the application fulfils the requirements of Table 2 of Annex V, in which case point (b) below applies.

(b)

If the Ctap is equal or above 2,5 μg/l but below 250 μg/l, the MTCtap shall not be higher than 250 μg/l.

3.1. The Ctap to be compared against the MTCtap value shall be determined based on the worst foreseeable conditions of use, including in terms of representativeness of the concentration in the material matrix, water, surface area to water volume, and temperature, as determined by ECHA and published on its website for each test method taking into account, in particular, the requirements for determination based on the worst foreseeable conditions of use and the appropriate EN standard.

4.1. Risk acceptance for starting substances for organic materials, organic cementitious constituents and compositions for enamels, ceramic and other inorganic materials

The starting substance, composition or constituent shall be accepted if Ctap < MTCtap for each relevant chemical species on the 10th day of testing according to point 5.2 in Table 1 of Annex IV.

4.2. Risk acceptance for metallic materials

For the assessment of the test rig results (according to standard EN 15664-1) the arithmetic mean of the equivalent pipe concentrations MEPn(T) analysed from relevant contact waters (see Annex IV, Section 1.1) shall be considered.

The composition can be accepted for a product group with the assumed contact surface a (see Table 2 of Annex II), if the following criteria are met for all required test waters:

(a)

MTCtap values are met for all analysed elements starting week 16 of testing;

(b)

Analysed metal concentrations are not showing increasing trend.