However, the Commission considered that instead of using data for Brazilian ARW producers, it was more reasonable to use the data available for the cooperating producer, Hands. The SG&A for Hands could not be used for the construction of the normal value under the chapeau of Article 2(6) of the basic Regulation, since Hands had no domestic sales in the ordinary course of trade. However, as a proxy for the SG&A related to Hands’ domestic sales, the Commission considered that the SG&A for all sales by Hands would be a reasonable alternative. Furthermore, the investigation did not show any differences between the SG&A for domestic and the SG&A for export sales, as all relevant costs were allocated on turnover. In addition, the number of sales made in Morocco by Hands was so small, that no meaningful comparison could be made. Hands’ data was verified and concerned sales by a company located in Morocco, which only produces and sells ARW. In addition, that data covered the investigation period only. The Commission considers the use of Brazilian data as less reasonable since the information available dated from 2019, and covered multiple products and production sites in several countries. The SG&A thus established on the basis of Hands’ own data, adjusted for items not directly related to the production of the product concerned and items that were not realized, was [12 % – 16 %].
59 3. DUMPING › 3.2. Normal value, Regulation (EU) 2023/99
In forcesince 11 Jan 2023