This methodology could not be accepted. First, because a comparison between the constructed normal value for one company and the export price of another company could not lead to an accurate dumping margin. This would mean comparing a value based on one company’s data with the export price of another company. Second, even if the Commission were to apply this method, it would not have been possible to carry it out on a product type level. Although the product types sold by Dika overlapped to a large extent those sold by Hands, they did not match completely. Some product types sold by Hands were not sold by Dika, and vice versa. Such methodology would thus not result in an accurate dumping margin which would be consistent with the reality of the export transactions carried out by Dika [In line with Case T-278/20 quoted in recital 92 and referred to by Dika in their submission.]. Moreover, such approach would be contrary to the requirement of Article 2(11) of the basic Regulation, which explicitly provides that, when calculating the dumping margin and regardless of the method of comparison of normal value and export price chosen, ‘the prices of all export transactions’ must be taken into account [See Cases C-376/15 P and C-377/15 P, Changshu City Standard Parts Factory and Ningbo Jinding Fastener Co. Ltd v Council of the European Union, ECLI:EU:C:2017:269, para. 53.]. Finally, this methodology would imply the disclosure of Hands’ confidential data to Dika, both regarding the product types sold and the export price. This cannot be accepted as Hands is the only other known producer of ARW in Morocco and in direct competition with Dika. The Commission therefore rejected this claim.
48 3. DUMPING › 3.1. Cooperation of exporting producers, Regulation (EU) 2023/99
In forcesince 11 Jan 2023
Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 5 April 2017. Changshu City Standard Parts Factory and Ningbo Jinding Fastener Co. Ltd v Council oDecision
5 Apr 2017 · 62015CJ0376
Judgment of the General Court (First Chamber) of 6 July 2022 (Extracts). Zhejiang Hangtong Machinery Manufacture Co. Ltd and Ningbo Hi-Tech Decision
6 Jul 2022 · 62020TJ0278