58 3. DUMPING › 3.2. Normal value, Regulation (EU) 2023/99

In forcesince 11 Jan 2023

In view of the arguments put forward concerning the use of Brazilian data for the construction of the normal value, the Commission reassessed the method it applied at provisional stage. The Commission disagreed with Hands that the Republic of Korea would be a more suitable alternative for Morocco than Brazil. The rationale behind article 2(6)(c) of the basic Regulation is to use a reasonable method to find a proxy for the SG&A and profit of the exporting producer under investigation. The chapeau of Article 2(6) of the basic Regulation, as well as subparagraphs (a) and (b) of that Article, show a clear preference for data related to production and sales in the domestic market of origin. Under Article 2(6)(c) therefore, a reasonable alternative for the domestic market would ideally be close to the domestic market, for example, in terms of economic development since that has an impact on the companies’ level of costs and profits. While Brazil was considered slightly more economically developed than Morocco, Korea as a highly developed economy could not be considered as a reasonable alternative for Morocco [The World Bank database has the following classifications for 2021 based on the gross national income (‘GNI’) per capita: lower-middle income economy between USD 1086 and USD 4255, upper-middle income between USD 4256 and USD 13205, high income economy above USD 13205. According to this classification, Morocco is considered as a lower-middle income economy (with a GNI for 2021 at USD 3350), Brazil as an upper-middle income economy (with GNI for 2021 at USD 7720) and Korea as a high income economy (with GNI for 2021 at USD 34980). See https://databank.worldbank.org/home.aspx].