159 5. CAUSATION › 5.1. Effects of the dumped imports › 5.1.2. Prices of the dumped imports from the country concerned and price effects, Regulation (EU) 2023/99

In forcesince 11 Jan 2023

ACEA and Hands claimed that, even in the absence of imports from Morocco, the Union industry would have been injured, thus demonstrating that imports from Morocco were not a cause of material injury. ACEA reiterated this claim after final disclosure. In particular, Union industry sales in 2020 and in the investigation period would have remained far below the 2019 levels in 2020 (-22 % in 2020 with Morocco and -20 % without Morocco) as well as in the investigation period (-18 % in the investigation period with Morocco and -14 % without Morocco). Injury in the investigation period could not be attributed to imports from Morocco, because in the investigation period as compared to 2020, the Union industry actually increased its sales (by 2281 thousand items) more than the Moroccan exporting producers (by 1478 thousand items). Thus, imports from Morocco had no volume impact. Furthermore, imports from Morocco could not have had a price impact in the investigation period since there was no significant price undercutting in tenders concluded during the investigation period, while sales prices of the imports from Morocco observed during the investigation period could not have had any negative impact on the contemporaneous sales of the Union industry.