136 4. INJURY › 4.4. Economic situation of the Union industry › 4.4.3. Microeconomic indicators › 4.4.3.1. Prices and factors affecting prices, Regulation (EU) 2023/99

In forcesince 11 Jan 2023

The Commission confirmed that usually contracts did not provide for any possibility to increase prices over the lifetime of a project to cover costs, save for the cost of aluminium ingots, and improve supplier’s profitability. In recital 113 of the provisional Regulation, the Commission did not argue that the possibility of ARW producers to increase their selling prices within the lifetime of a project exists, but rather explained that the ARW producers were unable to increase their prices when negotiating new tenders during the investigation period. In addition, the Commission collected evidence from the users and Union producers showing that the car manufacturers negotiated various types of discounts and rebates during the lifetime of a project, such as discounts calculated on the yearly overall turn-over, etc. Therefore, it is not accurate to argue that the prices are fixed (with the exception of the aluminium indexation) for the full lifetime of a project. Rather, prices could vary because of the aluminium indexation, but could not be increased further in order to take into account other costs such as labour, energy, raw materials or overheads costs. Furthermore, the actual selling prices may go further down throughout the lifetime of the project due to the various discounts and rebates that were applied. For one user, the amount of rebates or discounts obtained from an ARW producer was found to be significant. Therefore, the prices are not only determined based on the initial contract. The claim was therefore rejected.