The Commission addressed a similar argument in recital 192 below regarding underselling calculations. Indeed, the selection of individual tenders could not substitute the analysis made by the Commission, as this analysis was based on the complete and duly verified actual sales data, i.e. transaction sales listing and price comparison on a per type basis submitted by the sampled Union and exporting producers. This listing provided actual values on the quantity sold and invoiced during the investigation period, which, as explained in recital 136, often ultimately depart from those provided in the terms of a tender. Unlike the latter, the actual sales data takes account of discounts and rebates, deferred or not, which were actually issued and concerned the investigation period. Consequently, tender-base analysis would not reflect accurately the conditions of competition on the ARW market. Furthermore, ACEA did not contest that ARWs produced in Morocco have the same basic physical, chemical and technical characteristics as well as the same basic uses as the ARWs produced by the Union industry. Thus, unlike tender-based analysis, the comparison per product type correctly reflected the competition in prices and volumes between the imports from Morocco and the sales of the Union industry for the purposes of establishing price undercutting and price underselling. As indicated in its comments, ACEA explained that the tender contracts reflect and approximate number of wheels to be supplied, while the exact number is agreed typically within few weeks before the delivery, and that the success of a given car model depends on consumers and thus the volume of production of ARWs. Within each car model, several types of ARWs may be offered and car manufacturers cannot predict the total sales of each type throughout the production life of that car model. Even if the Commission were to consider the price effects at the level of the tenders, it observed that the data received on tenders was incomplete as it originated only from two cooperating users and could not be fully cross-checked with the data provided by the Union industry. In addition, one of the biggest users did not cooperate with the investigation and the partial data received on its behalf from ACEA could not be verified. Therefore, the claim was rejected.
115 4. INJURY › 4.3. Imports from the country concerned › 4.3.1. Prices of the imports from the country concerned and price undercutting, Regulation (EU) 2023/99
In forcesince 11 Jan 2023