96 7. RECOVERY › 7.1. Assessment › 7.1.10. Self-certification and self-declarations, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2103

In forcesince 3 Mar 2023

The Commission considers that the fact that some taxpayers may try to provide incorrect information in their self-declarations does not imply endorsing a partial recovery ex ante that would lead to a situation of unfairness and unequal treatment. According to settled case law, there is discrimination (i) where comparable situations are treated differently or (ii) where different situations are treated in the same way. [See for example the judgment of 11 December 2014, Austria v Commission, T-251/11, EU:T:2014:1060, paragraph 124, the judgment of 3 March 2016, Spain v Commission, C-26/15 P, EU:C:2016:132, paragraph 63 and judgment of 13 December 1984, Sermide SpA v Cassa Conguaglio Zucchero, C-106/83, EU:C:1984:394, paragraph 28.] A beneficiary that makes a fraudulent self-declaration or a beneficiary that cannot retrieve the information to be declared is not in the same situation as a beneficiary who can provide the required information and is willing to do so. Further, a beneficiary that makes a fraudulent self-declaration runs the risk of being caught during additional verifications and ex post checks and may be subject to fines on top of reimbursing the unlawful aid received.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Fifth Chamber), 11 December 2014. Republic of Austria v European Commission.Decision

    11 Dec 2014 · 62011TJ0251

  • Arrêt de la Cour (septième chambre) du 3 mars 2016. Royaume d'Espagne contre Commission européenne.Decision

    3 Mar 2016 · 62015CJ0026

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 13 December 1984. Sermide SpA v Cassa Conguaglio Zucchero and others.Decision

    13 Dec 1984 · 61983CJ0106

  • case:eu=C-106/83
  • celex=31926D0015