The Italian authorities argue that any effective recovery method must be based on conclusive and objective information. Recovery must be carried out in full compliance with the principles of legal certainty, legitimate expectations and right to be heard of the taxpayers, as expressly recognised in the Charter of Fundamental Rights. In their view, circumstantial evidence cannot be used to identify the aid beneficiaries and the recovery amounts. The Italian authorities consider that it is not possible to carry out a tax assessment on the basis of mere presumptions.
38 5. COMMENTS FROM THE ITALIAN AUTHORITIES AND INTERESTED THIRD PARTIES ON THE RECOVERY OF THE AID › 5.2. Comments received after the Judgment › 5.2.3. The rights of taxpayers and objective evidence, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2103
In forcesince 3 Mar 2023