In light of press articles suggesting that the beneficiaries of the ICI exemption were mostly entities belonging to the Catholic Church, the Italian authorities deem it necessary to explain that religious affiliation cannot be used to identify the recipients of aid. They submit that the Italian Constitution and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union prohibit discrimination based on religion, thus it is not possible to identify the beneficiaries based on religious affiliation. The Circular 2/DF of 26 January 2009 mentions “ecclesiastical bodies belonging to the Catholic Church and other religious denominations” among the entities that can be covered by the exemption at stake (see recitals (26)-(29) of the Final Decision). However, according to the Italian authorities, religious affiliation was not a criterion to determine the subjective scope of application of the ICI exemption. Circular 2/DF of 26 January 2009 clarified the notion of non-commercial entities and identified the criteria that the relevant activities performed by these entities should have fulfilled to benefit from the ICI exemption. Further, they point out that belonging to the Catholic Church was not a condition to benefit from the ICI exemption.
47 5. COMMENTS FROM THE ITALIAN AUTHORITIES AND INTERESTED THIRD PARTIES ON THE RECOVERY OF THE AID › 5.2. Comments received after the Judgment › 5.2.9. The identification of religious entities, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2103
In forcesince 3 Mar 2023