According to the Italian authorities, the IMU, introduced as from 2012, is different from the ICI and therefore the eligibility conditions for non-commercial entities to benefit from the tax exemption do not overlap [IMU declarations differ from ICI also in relation to other aspects. The IMU declarations allow to identify portions of real estate used for commercial and non-commercial activities.]. IMU declarations only show whether commercial activities were carried out in a specific year (as from 2012). [The Italian authorities explain that Article 13(12ter) of Decree-Law No 201/2011 provides that taxable persons must submit the IMU declaration by 30 June of the year following the year in which they took possession of the property or changes relevant to determining the tax took place. The declaration is also valid for subsequent years, provided the information declared does not change.] Since the eligibility conditions of the ICI exemption require determining the actual activity carried out in the real estate at the time the exemption was granted and the actual use of the real estate may change from one year to another, the information in the IMU declarations cannot be projected backwards to identify either the beneficiaries of the ICI exemption or the actual use of the real estate. For these reasons, the information contained in the IMU declarations could at best provide presumptive evidence that would not be appropriate in itself to provide the necessary legal certainty that the real estate was used on a commercial basis in the years the unlawful ICI exemption was in force, i.e. the years relevant for the recovery. Furthermore, no information would be available on beneficiaries from the ICI exemption that ceased or modified their activity or no longer own the property.
41 5. COMMENTS FROM THE ITALIAN AUTHORITIES AND INTERESTED THIRD PARTIES ON THE RECOVERY OF THE AID › 5.2. Comments received after the Judgment › 5.2.5. The IMU declarations, Decision_act (EU) 2023/2103
In forcesince 3 Mar 2023
- celex=32011R0201