In its position, the BKartA states that, with regard to its concrete practical and economic consequences, it is decisive that the market premium compensates for the difference between the plant-specific applicable value and the market value of the respective technology. Since it cannot become negative, it has an increasing effect on the plant operator’s profits if it is positive, i.e. if the plant-specific applicable value is higher than the corresponding market value. The BKartA performed an analysis of both values over 23 months between May 2020 and April 2022. As of 1 January 2021, the applicable values were set by law and are degressive over time at a rate between 0,5 and 1,5 percent per year. At least until around the middle of the year 2021, the applicable values were mostly significantly above the respective market values of the last 12 months. This meant that a correspondingly high market premium was paid, which isolated the RES plants concerned from the effective market and competitive forces of other electricity generation. Plants whose plant-specific applicable value exceeds the normal market value and which are consequently supported by the legally determined market premium are therefore, in the BKartA’s view, not exposed to direct competition from other generation plants.
38 3. ASSESSMENT › 3.2. Competition assessment › 3.2.3. Market analysis › 3.2.3.3. Renewable electricity plants that receive a remuneration linked to market prices (i.e. subject to direct marketing with legally determined value applicable [Section 20 of the EEG.], direct marketing with applicable value determined through tenders [Sections 20 and 22 of the EEG.], post-subsidised old renewable electricity plants [Section 23 b paragraph 2 of the EEG.] and renewable electricity plants subject to other direct marketing [Section 21 a of the EEG.]), Decision_act (EU) 2023/1978
In forcesince 21 Sep 2023