Second, the Commission did not apply the wrong temporal test. It referred in recital (49) to the fact that the date of the start of the production coincided with the date of the initiation of the original investigation. This finding, which was based on verified information provided by Turkiz Composite, was legally relevant, as one of the conditions of Article 13(2) of the basic anti-dumping Regulation [As referred to in recital (19), the legal standards contained in Article 13(2) of basic anti-dumping Regulation can by analogy be used in assessing the anti-subsidy case in the context of Article 23(3) of the basic Regulation.] is that ‘ ... the operation started or substantially increased since, or just prior to, the initiation of the anti-dumping investigation ...’. Article 23(3) of the basic Regulation defines circumvention and thus focuses on the imposition of the duty, since without a duty being imposed there cannot be circumvention. This does not preclude the commencement of a practice, process or work after the initiation of an investigation being considered as evidence that the duty subsequently imposed (and reasonably expected) was the justification for the practice in question. The reading of Article 23(3) proposed by the interested party would not only be incompatible with the language of Article 13(2) of the basic anti-dumping Regulation, quoted above, but would effectively remove circumvention practices that commence between the initiation of an investigation and the imposition of the duties from the scope of Article 23(3). This would go against the very purpose of Article 13 of the basic anti-dumping Regulation (and by analogy Article 23 of the basic Regulation), as defined by the Court. [Judgment of 8 June 2022, Guangxi Xin Fu Yuan Co. Ltd v European Commission, T-144/20, ECLI:EU:T:2022:346, para. 59 and the case-law cited.]
55 2. RESULTS OF THE INVESTIGATION › 2.4. Insufficient due cause or economic justification other than the imposition of the countervailing duty, Regulation (EU) 2022/1478
In forcesince 6 Sep 2022
Judgment of the General Court (Ninth Chamber) of 8 June 2022. Guangxi Xin Fu Yuan Co. Ltd v European Commission.Decision
8 Jun 2022 · 62020TJ0144