8 ANNEX VIII MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS ON THE PROCESS AND METHOD FOR CERTIFYING LOW INDIRECT LAND-USE CHANGE (ILUC) RISK BIOMASS, Regulation (EU) 2022/996

In forcesince 14 Jun 2022

To start the certification process, an economic operator has to submit an application to a certification body recognised by a voluntary scheme for low ILUC risk biomass certification. The applicant may be a farm, a first gathering point or a group manager, acting on behalf of a group of farmers.

The low ILUC risk certification application shall contain at least the following information:

(a)

the name and contact details of the applicant or applicants, including where relevant the members of a group for group certification [If applying for group certification, the application must include the name and contact details of the group manager and the name, contact details and locations of the farms/plantations that are part of the group.];

(b)

a description of the low ILUC risk additionality measures envisaged, including:

(i)

details on the delineated plot where the additionality measure will be implemented, including current land use, current management practices, current plot yield data, and if applicable a statement on whether the land is unused, abandoned or severely degraded;

(ii)

description of the additionality measures and an estimate of the additional biomass that will be produced following its application (either through a yield increase or production on unused, abandoned or severely degraded land);

(c)

information on any existing Commission-recognised voluntary scheme certification (name of the voluntary scheme, certificate number, status and validity period).

If the application is made after the additionality measures have been implemented, only the additional biomass produced after the date of low ILUC risk certification may be claimed as low ILUC risk.

Once the low ILUC risk application is accepted, the economic operator shall develop a management plan and submit it to the certification body. The management plan shall build on the information in the certification application, and include:

(a)

a definition of the delineated plot of land;

(b)

a description of additionality measures;

(c)

check on sustainability of the additionality measure against the requirements of Directive (EU) 2018/2001;

(d)

where relevant, demonstration of additionality assessment (either financial attractiveness or non-financial barrier test);

(e)

determination of the dynamic yield baseline, including:

(i)

for yield increase measures: at least 3 years of historical crop yield data related to the delineated plot of land;

(ii)

for cultivation on unused, abandoned or severely degraded land: proof of land status (the baseline yield for cultivation on unused, abandoned or severely degraded land is considered to be zero)

(f)

estimate of the additional biomass yield per year, with reference to the dynamic yield baseline for the delineated plot.

The management plan must allow a comparison to be made between the use of the delineated plot before and after implementation of the additionality measure.

[Replanting at the end of the crop lifetime is always necessary for a perennial crop. For replanting to count as an additionality measure, the economic operator must prove that their replanting goes beyond ‘business as usual’.]

Additionality category | Additionality measure | Example

Mechanisation | Machinery | Adoption of machinery that reduces/complements existing workforce input to boost output or reduce losses. This could include sowing, precision farming, harvesting machinery or machinery to reduce post-harvest losses.

Multi-cropping | Sequential cropping | Introduction of second crop on same land in the same year.

Management | Soil management | Mulching instead of ploughing, low tillage.

Fertilisation | Optimisation of fertilisation regime, use of precision agriculture.

Crop protection | Change in weed, pest and disease control.

Pollination | Improved pollination practices.

Other | Leaves room for innovation, combinations of measures and unforeseen developments.

Replanting (for perennial crops) | Choice of crop varieties | Higher yield variety, better adaptation to eco-physiological or climatic conditions.

Additionality measures are measures that go beyond common agricultural practices. Table 1 contains a non-exhaustive list of the types of yield increase additionality measures that economic operators can apply. Measures, or combinations of measures, shall boost output without compromising sustainability. The additionality measure shall not compromise future growing potential by creating a trade-off between short-term output gains and mid/long-term deterioration of soil, water and air quality and pollinator populations. The additionality measures shall not result in homogenisation of the agricultural landscape through removal of landscape elements and habitats such as solitary trees, hedgerows, shrubs, field edges or flower strips.

Only additional yield above the dynamic yield baseline may be claimed as low ILUC risk. Furthermore, an additionality measure may only be certified if it aims to achieve additional yields as a result of an improvement in agricultural practice. If a measure is applied that only aims to improve the sustainability of the plot, without improving yields, it is not deemed an additionality measure. This is not the case with cultivation on unused, abandoned or severely degraded land, in which case the cultivation itself is the additionality measure.

The economic operator will have to demonstrate that the management plan sets reasonable expectations on the yield increase by referring to, for example, scientific literature, experience from field trials, information from agronomy companies, seed/fertiliser developers or simple calculations. Satisfactory evidence supporting the expected yield increase of the additionality measure applied is needed for the project to be certified.

In the case of agricultural improvements, the agricultural practices applied, machinery and means before and after the additionality measure has been applied shall be documented in detail as part of the management plan. This shall allow a comparison in order to (i) determine whether an additionality measure has been implemented; (ii) evaluate if that additionality measure may be considered to be additional compared to a ‘business as usual’ development.

The financial attractiveness test shall demonstrate that the investment required for the additionality measure becomes financially attractive only if the resulting additional yield is certified as low ILUC risk. The analysis shall consist of a simple financial analysis of the envisaged low ILUC risk additionality measure investment.

The test shall include only those costs and yields that are directly related to the additionality measure investment. Normal operating costs of the entire farm shall therefore not be included in the analysis. The costs and revenues included in the test shall be related to the preparation, implementation, maintenance and decommissioning of the additionality measure that would not have been otherwise incurred.

Financial attractiveness arises from a business case in which the net present value (‘NPV’) [NPV is the difference between the present value of cash inflows and the present value of cash outflows over a period of time. NPV is used in capital budgeting and investment planning to analyse the profitability of a future investment or project. Source: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/n/npv.asp] of the investment is positive, which means that the investment may be conducted by the economic operator itself. As a result, only measures for which the business case analysis is negative (without the inclusion of a premium) shall pass the financial additionality test and become eligible to be certified as low ILUC risk. Outcomes above zero (a positive NPV) may still be eligible only if they pass the non-financial barrier test.

Formula to calculate the NPV of an investment:

Where:

Pexpected income from additional biomass (estimate of additional biomass x feedstock sales price without low ILUC premium)

Lcost of additionality measure (CAPEX and OPEX)

idiscount rate

ttime period

The parameters used in the NPV calculation shall be in line with the data included in the management plan.

The following parameters shall be included in the NPV calculation:

(a)

estimate of additional biomass volume;

(b)

feedstock sales price [currency/tonne]:

(i)

the feedstock sales price may be a single number extrapolated over the lifetime of the additional yield investment;

(ii)

this single number may be based on an average of actual historical feedstock sales values achieved by the economic operator. The average value shall be based on data for the same 3 years that the historical yield data used to set the dynamic yield baseline;

(iii)

in the event of introducing a new crop for which the economic operator does not have actual price data, this value may be based on price data from FAOSTAT [FAOSTAT producer prices. Source: http://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data/PP];

(c)

discount rate to be used: 3,5 % for high income countries [OECD countries] and 5,5 % for all other countries;

(d)

lifetime of the investment:

(i)

a lifetime of up to 10 years shall be used in conformity with the lifetime of the low ILUC risk certification (baseline validity);

(ii)

in some cases, the maximum lifetime of the investment may be set at 25 years based on the typical lifetime of perennial crops (that is to say, oil palm tree, in the case of oil palm replanting);

(e)

investment cost related to the additionality measure [CAPEX + OPEX].

The non-financial barrier analysis shall only cover non-financial project barriers that prevent the implementation of the additionality measures in case of no low ILUC risk certification. Any barrier whose cost can be estimated shall be included in the financial attractiveness analysis rather than in the non-financial barrier analysis.

The economic operator that plans the additionality measure is responsible for justifying the existence of non-financial barriers. The justification shall consist of a clear, verifiable description of the situation that prevents the uptake of the additionality measure. The economic operator shall provide all the necessary verifiable evidence to support the claim and demonstrate how low ILUC risk certification would ensure that the non-financial barrier is overcome.

The validity of the operator’s claim shall be assessed and validated by the baseline audit before issuing a low ILUC risk certificate.

The dynamic yield baseline shall be set individually for each delineated plot based on the crop and the type or combination of additionality measures applied. Plot-specific historical crop yield data from at least the 3 years preceding the application of an additionality measure shall be used to calculate the starting point of the dynamic yield baseline. This shall be combined with a global crop-specific trend line for expected yields based on historical data of actual yields over the past decade, or longer if data is available. For perennial crops, the dynamic yield baseline also takes into account the yield curve over the lifetime of the crop.

Where a farm rotates crops between fields and the crop whose yield will be increased (‘target crop’) has been planted in different fields on the same farm in previous years, two options are envisaged for gathering the historical yield data in order to calculate the dynamic yield baseline:

Option 1: The economic operator calculates an average of the yields for the 3 most recent years that the target crop was grown on the specific delineated plot prior to implementation of the additionality measure. As crops are grown in rotation, this may mean using data that is more than 5 years old.

Option 2: The economic operator calculates a weighted average of the yields of the 3 most recent years that the target crop was grown on the farm prior to implementation of the additionality measure, even if those yields were obtained from different plots of different sizes on the same farm.

If historical data for the 3 most recent years of crop yields is not available, whether inaccessible or not representative as per the auditor’s judgement, or if crop yield data is of insufficient quality, additional data may be obtained for earlier years or data from a neighbouring field growing the same crop under the same management plan. If 1 of the 3 years of historical data represents an exceptionally good or bad harvest (for example, discrepancy of 30 % or more compared to the other reference years), the outlier crop yield shall not be included in the calculation to avoid skewing the three-year average [In line with Article 2(7) of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/807, yield fluctuations should be excluded.].

The auditor is responsible for determining a yield outlier, based on their expert judgement, experience on the ground and knowledge of the economic operator’s practices over the long term. The auditor is also obliged to evaluate whether the crop yield data is of insufficient quality to be included as part of the baseline and annual audits, and to then decide whether a crop yield needs to be excluded or not.

The slope of the dynamic yield baseline shall be taken as the slope of a straight trend line fitted for yield developments of the target crop over the previous 10 years or longer if data is available. It is based on global data and shall be derived from the FAOSTAT World+ data for the relevant crop. This shall be done at the start of the certification period, and the slope shall be valid for the 10-year baseline validity period of the low ILUC certification.

Table 2 shows the slope of the dynamic yield baseline for the most common biofuel feedstock crops. These values are obtained by fitting a trend line over 20 years of global crop data obtained from FAOSTAT.

Slope-20 is based on 2008-2017.

Crop | Barley | Maize | Oil palm fruit | Rapeseed | Soybean | Sugar beet | Sugar cane | Sunflower seed | Wheat

Slope-20 | 0,035 | 0,074 | 0,200 | 0,036 | 0,028 | 1,276 | 0,379 | 0,035 | 0,04

For any crop in the table, the dynamic yield baseline is determined by taking the starting point (three-year average of historical yields prior to application of the additionality measure) and adding the global trend line (slope) from Table 2. The following formula shall be used, starting at the year the additionality measure is implemented:

DYBx = (starting point DYB) + (slope20)x

Where:

DYBxdynamic yield baseline in year x after implementation of the additionality measure

xyear(s) after implementation of additionality measure

If the additionality measure is to replace the existing crop with a different (higher yielding) crop on a delineated plot, the counterfactual situation is the cultivation of the existing crop. The dynamic yield baseline shall be determined based on historical yield and trend line data for the existing crop.

The starting point of the baseline shall be the 3-year average of the crop yield obtained for the lower performing existing crop. The trend line is based on the global FAOSTAT trend line data for the existing crop (see Table 2). This approach shall only be used if it can be demonstrated that the better performing crop could be introduced due to changes in the biofuel market, as demonstrated in the additionality assessment.

Depending on the yield variation observed over the lifetime of different types of perennial crop, different methodological approaches shall be possible.

For palm trees, the following data may be used by economic operators of oil palm plantations when determining their dynamic yield baseline:

(a)

the historical crop yields obtained prior to implementation of an additionality measure;

(b)

the planting year of palm trees on the delineated plot of land and/or their age profile;

(c)

the cultivars of palm trees on the delineated plot, if applicable;

(d)

the area of land replanted each year on a plantation, if applicable.

That data is combined with a growth curve to determine the dynamic yield baseline. The key characteristic from the growth curve shall be the shape, not the magnitude of the yield.

The growth curve gives the shape and it needs to be combined with the historical yield data and age of the trees, as set out in points (a) and (b), to adjust the magnitude of the dynamic yield baseline curve to the specific plot.

The following three options are available for determining the dynamic yield baseline for palm trees.

For each option, the data required to set the dynamic yield baselines must include:

(a)

Option 1a: Standard growth curve

(i)

3 most recent years of historical crop yields for palm trees grown on the delineated plot;

(ii)

age of trees on the delineated plot/planting year;

(b)

Option 1b: Economic operator provides growth curve [To use this option, economic operators have to show that the correlation between the standard growth curve and their baseline growth curve is less than 0,8.]

(i)

3 most recent years of historical crop yield for palm trees grown on the delineated plot;

(ii)

age of trees on the delineated plot/planting year;

(iii)

the cultivars of palm trees on the delineated plot;

(iv)

economic operator’s own reference growth curve.

(c)

Option 2: Group certification approach

(i)

for the 3 most recent years, the total hectares and total yield in fresh fruit bunches (FFB) for palm trees grown on the delineated plot/plantation(s), producing palm as part of the group.

Options 1a and 1b apply where an additionality measure is taken on a stand of trees that are the same age, or if the age profile of the trees on the delineated plot(s) is known and does not remain constant year after year.

Option 2 may be applied when the age profile of the trees on the delineated plots is mixed and remains relatively constant year after year, that is to say in a group certification approach or if a consistent percentage of a plantation area is replanted each year, resulting in a constant age profile for the trees.

Option 2 shall not be used if more than 20 % of the volume in the group comes from the same plantation, or if more than 5 % of the total area in the group is being replanted in the same year. In that case, option 1a or b shall be used to determine the baseline.

The first option uses the shape of a pre-established ‘standard’ growth curve (based on existing scientific evidence) to determine the dynamic yield baseline for a delineated plot. The standard curve has been normalised and is shown in Figure 1 and Table 3 below.

The dynamic yield baseline is determined by using the 3 most recent years of historical crop yield data for the specific plot and the age of the palm trees when that yield was observed, and using the annual percentage yield change from the standard curve to form a ‘business-as-usual’ yield curve relevant to the specific plot.

[After 25 years, the yield would be expected to continue to decline. However, as the typical lifetime of an oil palm tree is around 25 years, there is a lack of data to support the magnitude of the decline after 25 years. Therefore, a conservative approach is taken to assume that the yield curve would remain at the 25-year level.]

Years after planting | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13

Normalised yield | 0 | 0 | 0,147 | 0,336 | 0,641 | 0,833 | 0,916 | 0,968 | 0,996 | 1 | 0,999 | 0,980 | 0,965

Years after planting | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | ≥ 26

Normalised yield | 0,945 | 0,926 | 0,910 | 0,906 | 0,888 | 0,870 | 0,858 | 0,842 | 0,836 | 0,815 | 0,806 | 0,793 | 0,793

Option 1a involves the following methodological steps:

1.

To determine the average historical crop yield, collect the three most recent historical crop yields observed on the delineated plot prior to implementation of the additionality measure, as well as the corresponding age of the trees when those yields were observed;

2.

Calculate an average (mean) of the three historical crop yields;

3.

Based on the age of the trees when the historical yield data is from, determine where this average historical crop yield shall be on the standard growth curve (e.g. if the yield data is from trees aged 7, 8 and 9 years, the average historical yield should be considered to be year 8);

4.

To determine the next point of the dynamic yield baseline, multiply the average historical crop yield from step 2 by the corresponding calculated annual percentage change, derived from the standard growth curve (Table 4 below). Repeat this for each subsequent point to plot the dynamic yield baseline;

[After 25 years, the yield would be expected to continue to decline. However, as the typical lifetime of an oil palm tree is around 25 years, there is a lack of data to support the magnitude of the decline after 25 years. Therefore, a conservative approach is taken to assume that the yield curve would remain at the 25-year level.]

Years after planting | 1 to 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14

Annual percentage change | - | 128,0 % | 90,6 % | 30,0 % | 10,0 % | 5,6 % | 2,9 % | 0,4 % | -0,1 % | -1,9 % | -1,6 % | -2,0 %

Years after planting | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | ≥ 26

Annual percentage change | -2,1 % | -1,7 % | -0,5 % | -1,9 % | -2,0 % | -1,4 % | -1,8 % | -0,8 % | -2,5 % | -1,1 % | -1,6 % | 0 %

5.

To incorporate the global yield trend in the dynamic yield baseline, apply the compound annual growth rate (CAGR) calculated from FAOSTAT World+ yield data (Table 5 below), to each point of the dynamic yield baseline to obtain the CAGR corrected dynamic yield baseline.

Based on FAOSTAT World+ 2008-2017

Annual performance increase palm – business as usual | 1,37 %

This option may be used in exceptional cases, if the economic operator can demonstrate that option 1a is not appropriate for their specific case. In such a case, if the economic operator has an expected growth curve determined based on the available data of palm seedlings (that relates to their ‘business-as-usual’ scenario), that curve may be used as the basis for the dynamic yield baseline instead of using the standard growth curve. All steps described in Option 1a shall be followed, replacing the standard growth curve with the economic operator’s own curve. The economic operator shall therefore calculate the annual percentage change.

The plot-specific growth curve shall still be corrected for global yield development using the CAGR calculated FAOSTAT World+ yield data (Table 5).

In the case of group certification, or when a first gathering point or mill acts as the unit of certification, the dynamic yield baseline may be set using a similar ‘straight line’ dynamic yield baseline approach as used for annual crops. This approach may be used if a group manager, first gathering point or mill is seeking to certify a group that is taking the same additionality measure, and when the plantation or area supplying the mill contains a mix of ages of trees meaning that the annual yield supplying the mill has remained relatively constant.

This article is long: the rest is at the official publication.