5 ANNEX V METHODOLOGY FOR DETERMINING THE EMISSION SAVINGS FROM SOIL CARBON ACCUMULATION VIA IMPROVED AGRICULTURAL MANAGEMENT, Regulation (EU) 2022/996

In forcesince 14 Jun 2022

Economic operators seeking to claim emission savings from soil carbon accumulation via improved agricultural management (esca) in terms of g CO2eq/MJ should use the following formula to calculate their actual values:

Where:

CSRis the mass of soil carbon stock per unit area associated with the reference crop management practice in Mg of C per ha.

CSAis the mass of soil estimated carbon stock per unit area associated with the actual crop management practices after at least 10 years of application in Mg of C per ha.

3,664is the quotient obtained by dividing the molecular weight of CO2 (44,010 g/mol) by the molecular weight of carbon (12,011 g/mol) in g CO2eq/g C.

nis the period (in years) of the cultivation of the crop considered.

Pis the productivity of the crop (measured as MJ biofuel or bioliquid energy per ha per year).

efemissions from the increased fertilisers or herbicide use

Improved agriculture management practices, accepted for the purpose of achieving emission savings from soil carbon accumulation, include shifting to reduced or zero-tillage, improved crop/rotation, the use of cover crops, including crop residue management, and the use of organic soil improver (e.g. compost, manure fermentation, digestate, biochar, etc.).

The calculation of the actual values of CSR and CSA shall be based on measurements of soil carbon stocks. The measurement of CSR shall be carried out at farm level before the management practice changes in order to establish a baseline, and then the CSA shall be measured at regular intervals no later than 5 years apart.

The entire area for which the soil carbon stocks are calculated shall have a similar climate and soil type as well as similar management history in terms of tillage and carbon input to soil. If the improved management practices are only applied to part of the farm, the GHG emissions savings can only be claimed for the area covered by them. If different improved management practices are applied on a single farm, a claim of GHG emission savings shall be calculated and claimed individually for each esca practice.

To ensure reduced year-to-year fluctuations in the measured soil carbon stocks and to reduce associated errors, fields that have the same soil and climate characteristics, similar management history in terms of tillage and carbon input to soil and that will be subject to the same improved management practice may be grouped, including those fields belonging to different farmers.

After the first measurement of the baseline, the increase in soil carbon can be estimated based on representative experiments or soil models, before a second measurement of the increase in carbon stock is made. From the second measurement onwards, the measurements shall constitute the ultimate basis for determining the actual values of the increase in soil carbon stock.

However, after the second measurement, modelling to enable economic operators to estimate the annual increase in soil carbon stocks may only be permitted until the next measurement if the models used have been calibrated, based on the real values measured. Economic operators shall be obliged to use only models that have been validated by voluntary schemes. Voluntary schemes shall be obliged to inform the economic operators and the certification bodies, performing audits on their behalf, about the models that they have validated for such use.

The models used shall take into account the different soil, climate and field management history to simulate carbon dynamics in soil. The voluntary scheme shall be obliged to prepare a detailed report, presenting the validated modelling method used and its underlying assumptions. The related final actual values that are established based on the soil measurement results, shall be used to adjust the annual claims of emissions savings from soil carbon accumulation via agricultural management (esca), made on the basis of modelling.

To claim emissions savings from soil carbon accumulation via agricultural management (esca), measurements of soil carbon stocks shall be performed by certified laboratories and samples shall be retained for a period of at least 5 years for auditing purposes.

A long-term commitment by the farmer or economic operator to continue applying the improved management practice for a minimum of 10 years shall be required by voluntary schemes in order for GHG emission savings to be taken into account. Such commitment may be implemented as a 5-years renewable commitment.

Failure to meet this criterion will lead to all esca values of the current year for the farmer or economic operator being added as emissions to the overall GHG emissions of the energy crop delivered, instead of being deducted as a GHG emission savings and a prohibition to include an esca value in the GHG calculations for 5 years, whatever the certification scheme used. If a commitment has been signed in the name of an economic operator on behalf of several farmers and one of these farmers withdraws early, the above-mentioned penalties shall apply only to the farmer concerned and not to all the commitments of the economic operator. The voluntary scheme that has issued the certificate shall be obliged to enforce the penalties and dully inform all other voluntary schemes as well as to publish this information on its website and included it in the annual activity reports to be sent to the Commission.

In addition, a continuous minimum period of 3 years for the application of the improved management practice shall be required before a claim can be made.

The maximum possible total value of the annual claim of emission savings from soil carbon accumulation due to improved agricultural management (esca) shall be capped to 45 g CO2eq/MJ biofuel or bioliquid for the entire period of application of the Esca practices, if biochar is used as organic soil improver alone or in combination with other eligible esca practices. In all other cases, the cap referred to above shall be 25 g CO2eq/MJ biofuel or bioliquid for the entire period of application of the esca practices.

Primary producers or economic operators, who are already engaged in eligible esca practices and have made respective Esca claims before the entry into force of this Implementing regulation, may apply a cap of 45 g CO2eq/MJ biofuel or bioliquid in a transition period until the first measurement of the carbon stock increase is made at the 5th year. In such a case, the measured carbon stock increase at the 5th year will become a cap for the annual claims to be made in the following period of 5 years. If the first measurement of the carbon stock increase at the 5th year shows higher total annual carbon stock increase, compared to the annual claims made, the annual difference can be claimed by primary producers or economic operators in subsequent years to compensate for lower carbon stock increases. Respectively, if the first measurement of the carbon stock increase at the 5th year shows lower total annual soil carbon stock increase, compared to the annual claims made, the annual difference has to be deducted accordingly by farmers or economic operators from their claims in the subsequent 5 years.

If the application of eligible improved agricultural management practices (esca) started in the past but no previous Esca claims were made, annual retroactive Esca claims can be made but for no longer than 3 years prior to the moment of esca certification. The economic operator shall be obliged to provide adequate evidence about the start of the application of the improved farming practices. In such a case, the estimate of the CSR value can be based on a comparative measurement of a neighbouring or other field with similar climatic and soil conditions as well as similar field management history. If there is no available data from such a field, the CSRestimated value can be based on modelling. In that case, a first measurement shall be done immediately, at the moment of commitment. The next measurement of carbon stock increase will have to be made 5 years later.

The increased emissions resulting from the increased fertilisers or herbicide use due to the application of improved agricultural practices, shall be considered. For this purpose, adequate evidence shall be provided on the historic use of fertilisers or herbicide that shall be counted as the average for the 3 years before the application of the new agricultural practices. The contribution of nitrogen fixation crops used to reduce the need for additional fertilisers can be considered in the calculations.

The following rules shall be applied to sampling:

1.

Representative sampling method:

(a)

sampling shall be made for each plot or field;

(b)

at least one grab sample of 15 well distributed sub-samples per every 5 hectares or per field, whichever is smaller (taking into account the heterogeneity of the plot’s carbon content), shall be taken;

(c)

smaller fields with same climatic conditions, soil type, reference farming practice, and esca practice can be grouped;

(d)

sampling shall be done either in spring before soil cultivation and fertilisation or in autumn, a minimum of 2 months after harvest;

(e)

direct measurements of soil carbon stock changes shall be taken for the first 30 cm of soil;

(f)

the points of the initial sampling to measure the baseline of soil carbon stocks shall be used under identical field conditions (especially soil moisture);

(g)

The sampling protocol shall be well documented.

2.

Measurement of the soil carbon content:

(a)

soil samples shall be dried, sieved, and if necessary grounded;

(b)

if the combustion method is used, inorganic carbon shall be excluded.

3.

Determination of dry bulk density:

(a)

changes in bulk density over time shall be taken into account;

(b)

bulk density should be measured using the tapping method, that is to say by mechanically tapping a cylinder into the soil, which greatly reduces any errors associated with bulk density measurement;

(c)

if the tapping method is not possible, especially with sandy soils, a reliable method shall be used instead;

(d)

samples should be oven-dried prior to weighing.

The application of the above methodology on esca and the calculation of the actual GHG emissions values shall be duly verified by certification bodies and documented in audit reports. Voluntary schemes are obliged to issue detailed guidance on the application of this methodology, including on their validated soil models to economic operators and certification bodies as well as to support their auditors in their verification tasks. Voluntary schemes shall be also obliged to include detailed statistical information and qualitative feedback on the implementation of the esca methodology in their annual activity reports to be submitted to the Commission.

The Commission shall duly monitor the implementation of the esca methodology as part of its monitoring of the activities of the voluntary schemes covering inter alia:

Project implementation which should allow for, amongst others, evaluating the relation of modelling results against field measurements;

Comparing claims and results against estimates of SOC saturation to derive criteria and recommendations and possibly requirements for long term maintenance of a given equilibrium to secure results in the long term;

Derive recommendations and requirements for an appropriate model selection and calibration as well as reliable indicators to model results.

The Commission may revise the methodological approach described in this annex as well as the caps applied to annual claims of carbon stock accumulation, based on the outcomes of this monitoring or with the aim to align it with evolving knowledge or with new legislation in this area in the future (i.e. EU carbon farming initiative).