57 2. RESULTS OF THE INVESTIGATION › 2.4. Nature of circumvention practices for which there was insufficient due cause or economic justification, Regulation (EU) 2021/1474

In force

The Commission acknowledged that the input material undergoes several processes before it is sold as the product under investigation by Dingheng. However, these cannot be seen as major operations, at least not when compared to the production process that takes place before the input material arrives at the Dingheng production site. The production process of aluminium foil stock involves melting aluminium ingots, casting, sawing, scalping, heating, several stages of hot- and cold rolling and annealing. The following steps to turn the foil stock into jumbo rolls are therefore comparatively relatively minor in scope and, as shown in recital (82) below, of a relatively limited added value, which is the relevant criterion in this respect. In addition, the change in customs heading cannot be considered as proof of the impact of the operations performed on the input material. In fact, Article 13(1)(a) of the basic Regulation explicitly mentions as a circumvention practice ‘the slight modification of the product concerned to make it fall under customs codes which are normally not subject to the measures’. The claims made by the Dingsheng Group were therefore rejected.