The Commission disagreed. Regarding the alleged unreliability of the data used for the analysis, the applicant based its analysis on the data that was reasonably available to it, as set out in recital (15), and the evidence thus provided was considered sufficient to initiate the investigation. The fact that calculations were based on only one of the CN codes (76071119) did not undermine the accuracy of the request. As pointed out by the applicant in its rebuttal of Dingsheng Group’s submission, the General Court held that ‘the basic regulation does not require, where the product concerned contains several types of products, as in the present case, that the complaint should provide information on all those product types’. [Judgment of 15 December 2016 in Case RENV, Gul Ahmed Textile Mills v Council, T-199/04, paragraph 100.] It was not contested by the Dingsheng Group that this particular CN code covered the most representative product types. In fact, import data from Comext at 10-digit TARIC level showed that during the investigation period there were no imports at all of the products falling under the other CN code (76071190). Therefore, including that CN code would not have changed the outcome of the analysis in the request.
20 1. PROCEDURE › 1.5. Comments on initiation, Regulation (EU) 2021/1474
In force
Judgment of the General Court (Seventh Chamber) of 27 September 2011. Gul Ahmed Textile Mills Ltd v Council of the European Union.Decision
27 Sep 2011 · 62004TJ0199
Arrêt du Tribunal (cinquième chambre) du 15 décembre 2016. Gul Ahmed Textile Mills Ltd contre Conseil de l'Union européenne.Decision
15 Dec 2016 · 62004TJ0199(01)