170 VII. RECOVERY, Decision_act (EU) 2020/394

In forcesince 7 Oct 2019

The Commission does not at this stage accept the argument of Greece that there is absolute impossibility to recover [See Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 6 November 2018 in Joined Cases C-622/16P to C-624/16P, Scuola Elementare Maria Montessori v Commission, EU:C:2018:873, paragraphs 96-97. See further on the interpretation of the concept of absolute impossibility to recover as the sole exception to the obligation to recover State aid declared incompatible by the Commission: Notice from the Commission, ‘Towards an effective implementation of Commission decisions ordering Member States to recover unlawful and incompatible State aid’, OJ C 272, 15.11.2007, p. 4, points 18-20 and case-law cited therein.]. In this regard two cumulative conditions must be satisfied following a detailed examination by the Commission, namely that the difficulties relied on by the Member State concerned are real and that there are no alternative methods of recovery. Only if the Commission had found, following such a detailed examination, that there were no alternative methods allowing even partial recovery of the unlawful aid in question might that recovery have been considered to be objectively and absolutely impossible to carry out. In the present case, Greece did not rule out alternative methods for at least partial recovery, relying solely on the fact that it is not possible to obtain the necessary information on direct and indirect damage caused by the fires, in the absence of any records and documentation thereof. For example, it is not clear if the damage can be approximated on the basis of aerial photographs at the time of the fires, public records or other means. Therefore, the request not to order the recovery of the incompatible State aid cannot be accepted at this stage.

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 6 November 2018. Scuola Elementare Maria Montessori Srl v European Commission, European Commission Decision

    6 Nov 2018 · 62016CJ0622