Finally, given that the Board of Management and Assessment of the responsibility for guarantees of the Greek State evaluated all applications for State guarantees under these schemes before their final approval, the opening decision stated that the Greek authorities could not subsequently argue that the approved State guarantees were null and void ex tunc (see recital 49 of the present Decision). The Greek authorities challenged this finding (see recital 96 of the present Decision), arguing that such a retroactive revocation of the State guarantees could occur if the conditions of their implementation are not fulfilled subsequently by the relevant financial institution. This argument ultimately touches on the question of the imputability of these State guarantees. It should be noted in this regard that the aid is granted at the moment when the State guarantee is granted, not when the guarantee is invoked or the payments are made. Furthermore, the question whether the guarantee constitutes State aid is to be assessed at the moment the guarantee is granted [Commission Notice on guarantees, Sections 2.1; see also ‘Commission Notice of 2000’, Section 2.1.2.]. Thus, since the State guarantees granted under these schemes had been previously evaluated and found by the Board, an indisputably State organ, to fulfil the applicable conditions, they cannot be considered afterwards not to be imputable to the State and never to have been granted. It would of course be a completely different scenario and irrelevant for the present assessment, if financial institutions outside the control of the State misconstrued the relevant legal bases and independently from the State granted loans on the apparent understanding that these were covered by the schemes in question although the applicable conditions had not been complied with.
133 V. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › 1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › Existence of aid in the case of State guarantees, Decision_act (EU) 2020/394
In forcesince 7 Oct 2019