However, before reaching a final conclusion on the existence of aid in the case of State guarantees, it is necessary to assess whether all the conditions which allow to exclude the existence of that aid as provided in Section 3.4 of the Commission Notice on guarantees [See also ‘Commission Notice of 2000’, Section 3.4.] are fulfilled. The opening decision raised doubts as regards the fulfilment of at least some of the conditions, whereas the Greek authorities challenged that view. It should be noted that these conditions are cumulative, namely that the failure to fulfil even one of them is sufficient for the State guarantee to be considered State aid based on the assessment in recitals 124-128. This is indeed the case here, as the borrowers did not have to pay any premium, as is required by the Commission notice on guarantees. It must therefore be concluded that the schemes were not self-financing; there was no annual review of the appropriate premium foreseen; the administrative costs of the scheme were not covered and there was no yearly remuneration of an adequate capital. Furthermore, the legal bases of the schemes did not refer to the possibility to use safe-harbour premiums or single premiums for SMEs where applicable. Finally, there was no determination of eligible companies in terms of rating, thereby affecting the overall transparency of the schemes. None of these elements were included in the legal bases of the schemes, whilst the Greek authorities failed to provide evidence to the contrary.
129 V. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › 1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › Existence of aid in the case of State guarantees, Decision_act (EU) 2020/394
In forcesince 7 Oct 2019