To fall within the scope of Article 107(1) TFEU the aid measure must favour ‘certain undertakings or the production of certain goods’. The fact that the aid is not aimed at one or more specific recipients defined in advance, but that it is subject to a series of objective criteria according to which it may be granted, within the framework of a predetermined overall budget allocation, to an indefinite number of beneficiaries who are not initially individually identified, is insufficient to call into question the selective nature of the measure [Judgment of the General Court of 29 September 2000, Confederación Espanola de Transporte de Mercancías v Commission, Case T-55/99, EU:T:2000:223, para. 40. See also judgment of the General Court of 13 September 2012, Italy v Commission, Case T-379/09, EU: T:2012:422, para. 47.]. In addition, in principle, only measures that apply within the entire territory of the Member State escape the regional selectivity criterion laid down in Article 107(1) TFEU [See judgment of the Court of First Instance, Salzgitter v Commission, Case T-308/00, EU:T:2004:199, para. 38 (this part of the judgment was approved on appeal in Case C-408/04 P, Commission v Salzgitter, EU:C:2008:236, para. 109. In the above-referred judgment the Court explicitly ruled that: ‘It does not matter that the selective nature of the measure flows, from […] a criterion relating to geographic location in a defined part of the territory of a Member State. What matters, however, for a measure to be found to be State aid, is that the recipient undertakings belong to a specific category determined by the application, in law or in fact, of the criterion established by the measure in question’.].
117 V. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › 1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU, Decision_act (EU) 2020/394
Arrêt du Tribunal (première chambre) du 19 octobre 2022. Sogia Ellas AE contre Commission européenne.Decision
Il en résulte que c’est sans commettre d’erreur de droit ni d’erreur d’appréciation et sans adopter un raisonnement contradictoire que la Commission a, en substance, estimé, d’une part, aux considérants 113 à 116 de la …
19 Oct 2022 · 62020TJ0347
Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Third Chamber, extended composition) of 29 September 2000. Confederación Española de Transporte de Decision
29 Sep 2000 · 61999TJ0055
Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 22 April 2008. Commission of the European Communities v Salzgitter AG.Decision
22 Apr 2008 · 62004CJ0408
Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Fourth Chamber, extended composition) of 1 July 2004. Salzgitter AG v Commission of the European CoDecision
1 Jul 2004 · 62000TJ0308
Arrêt du Tribunal (septième chambre) du 13 septembre 2012. République italienne contre Commission européenne.Decision
13 Sep 2012 · 62009TJ0379
- case:eu=T-308/00 (several documents carry this name)
- celex=31955D0099
- ecli=ECLI:EU:C:2004:199