Member States should ensure that in the assessment of statements made by suspects or accused persons or of evidence obtained in breach of their right to a lawyer, or in cases where a derogation from that right was authorised in accordance with this Directive, the rights of the defence and the fairness of the proceedings are respected. In this context, regard should be had to the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights, which has established that the rights of the defence will, in principle, be irretrievably prejudiced when incriminating statements made during police interrogation without access to a lawyer are used for a conviction. This should be without prejudice to the use of statements for other purposes permitted under national law, such as the need to execute urgent investigative acts to avoid the perpetration of other offences or serious adverse consequences for any person or related to an urgent need to prevent substantial jeopardy to criminal proceedings where access to a lawyer or delaying the investigation would irretrievably prejudice the ongoing investigations regarding a serious crime. Further, this should be without prejudice to national rules or systems regarding admissibility of evidence, and should not prevent Member States from maintaining a system whereby all existing evidence can be adduced before a court or a judge, without there being any separate or prior assessment as to admissibility of such evidence.
Recital 50, Directive (EU) 2013/48
Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 7 September 2023. Criminal proceedings against.Decision
The intention of the EU legislature to recognise such discretion is confirmed by the recitals of Directives 2012/13 and 2013/48. First, according to recital 36 of Directive 2012/13 the right to challenge the possible failure or refusal of …
7 Sep 2023 · 62022CJ0209
Opinion of Advocate General Ćapeta delivered on 22 February 2024. Criminal proceedings against M.S. and Others.Decision
In light of those facts, the referring court submitted the following questions to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling: Must Article 6(1), (2), (3)(a) and (7) and Article 18, in conjunction with recitals 25, 26 and 27, of …
22 Feb 2024 · 62022CC0603
Opinion of Advocate General Pikamäe delivered on 23 March 2023. Criminal proceedings against.Decision
This interpretation of the provisions of Directives 2012/13 and 2013/48 is confirmed by their respective recitals. Thus, recital 36 of Directive 2012/13 states that the right to challenge the possible failure or refusal of the competent …
23 Mar 2023 · 62022CC0209
Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 5 September 2024. Criminal proceedings against M.S. and Others.Decision
Moreover, it is apparent from Directives 2012/13 and 2013/48 that there are no clear provisions in EU law relating to the possibility of using statements made by a suspected or accused child in the absence of a lawyer as evidence. However, …
5 Sep 2024 · 62022CJ0603
Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 8 May 2025. Criminal proceedings against K.P.Decision
Consequently, nothing in those directives requires the national court to disapply automatically all of the evidence obtained in breach of the rights conferred by Directives 2013/48 and 2016/1919. However, in accordance with the case-law of …
8 May 2025 · 62023CJ0530
Opinion of Advocate General Collins delivered on 11 April 2024. Criminal proceedings against CH.Decision
Recital 50 of Directive 2013/48 provides that the obligation to ensure that the rights of the defence and the fairness of the proceedings are respected should be without prejudice to national rules or systems regarding the admissibility of …
11 Apr 2024 · 62024CC0015