Member States should also be permitted to derogate temporarily from the right of access to a lawyer in the pre-trial phase where immediate action by the investigating authorities is imperative to prevent substantial jeopardy to criminal proceedings, in particular to prevent destruction or alteration of essential evidence, or to prevent interference with witnesses. During a temporary derogation on that ground, the competent authorities may question suspects or accused persons without a lawyer being present, provided that they have been informed of their right to remain silent and can exercise that right, and provided that such questioning does not prejudice the rights of the defence, including the privilege against self-incrimination. Questioning may be carried out for the sole purpose and to the extent necessary to obtain information that is essential to prevent substantial jeopardy to criminal proceedings. Any abuse of this derogation would in principle irretrievably prejudice the rights of the defence.
Recital 32, Directive (EU) 2013/48
In forcecited 2×
Opinion of Advocate General Bobek delivered on 7 November 2019. Criminal proceedings against VW.Decision
Although Directive 2013/48 does not define the concept of ‘substantial jeopardy’ to the proceedings, it does give some examples in recital 32, where it refers to ‘destruction or alteration of essential evidence’ and ‘interference …
7 Nov 2019 · 62018CC0659
Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 12 March 2020. Criminal proceedings against VW.Decision
Recitals 4, 6, 19 and 30 to 32 of Directive 2013/48 state: The implementation of the principle of mutual recognition of decisions in criminal matters presupposes that Member States trust in each other’s criminal justice systems. The …
12 Mar 2020 · 62018CJ0659