With regard to Germany’s second argument, that the exception provided in §8c(1a) KStG to the general prohibition on loss carry-forward in the event of a change of ownership laid down by §8c(1) KStG was justified by the ratio legis of §8c(1) KStG, because there was no risk of abuse in the case of the restructuring of a company in difficulty, the Commission observes that this argument does not justify the restriction of §8c(1a) KStG to companies in difficulty. The Commission points out that there is no risk of abuse either when a financially sound company is acquired. The risk of abuse exists only in relation to empty-shell companies. As pointed out above, the ratio legis of §8c(1) KStG goes further than combating abuse. Its objective is also to increase the German corporate tax base and to offset the reduction in the corporate income tax rate from 25 % to 15 %. This explains why §8c(1) KStG also includes a number of acquisitions of interests where there is no risk of abuse. The Commission therefore rejects Germany’s argument that the exception introduced by §8c(1a) KStG corresponds to the ratio legis of §8c(1) KStG.
92 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURE › 5.2. Selective advantage › 5.2.3. Justification on the basis of the nature or the general scheme of the tax system of which it is part, Decision_act (EU) 2011/527
In forcesince 26 Jan 2011