With regards to Germany’s argument that a company in difficulty has no choice for but to obtain finance through an investor, whereas a healthy company, which is temporarily loss-making, has the choice between obtaining finance on the capital market and acquisition by an investor with subsequent refinancing, the Commission is of the opinion that the way a company finances its business is irrelevant in the light of the objective of the tax system. A corporate tax system is based on the taxation of profits and the declaration of losses. As could be observed during the financial and economic crisis, financially sound companies also reported losses temporarily. But these financially sound companies are not eligible for the loss carry-forward in application of the Sanierungsklausel and are thus at disadvantage compared with ailing loss-making companies in the event of a change of ownership and subsequent refinancing by the new shareholders. Furthermore, the Commission also notes that during the financial and economic crisis healthy companies, which temporarily recorded losses, had great difficulties accessing the capital markets. Therefore, even the factual assumptions underlying the first argument are inaccurate. The Commission therefore rejects Germany’s first argument.
91 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURE › 5.2. Selective advantage › 5.2.3. Justification on the basis of the nature or the general scheme of the tax system of which it is part, Decision_act (EU) 2011/527
In forcesince 26 Jan 2011