181 VIII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › VIII.2. Tax deduction for equalisation provisions relating to certain supplementary group insurance policies › Analysis of the compatibility of the measure under other provisions of Article 107(2) and (3) TFEU, Decision_act (EU) 2011/319

In force

Regarding the compatibility of the measure on the basis of Article 107(3)(c) TFEU, France states that the established social objective of the measure proves the importance for the future of developing the personal protection market. This development is said to be part of an objective in favour of public health, combating insecurity, economic and social cohesion, the development of social dialogue, and the protection of workers, which are European Union objectives in the common interest. The Commission nevertheless considers that the need for and proportionality of the measure have not been proven. As it has already stated in its examination of the existence of an advantage, the Commission is of the opinion that there is nothing to justify the exclusion from the benefit of the measure for group policies at company level covering the same risks but not concluded under designation. The measure is therefore disproportionate in so far as it does not include policies outside designation. Moreover, it should be noted, as the Commission has already done for the first measure, that the measure constitutes a continuous reduction in charges which constitutes operating aid which is not, according to established practice, capable of being declared compatible under Article 107(3) TFEU.