131 VIII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › VIII.1. Exemption from corporation tax and local business tax for management operations connected with contrats solidaires et responsables › Analysis of the compatibility of the measure under Article 107(2)(a) TFEU, Decision_act (EU) 2011/319

In force

The Commission notes firstly that no precise information could be supplied by the French authorities concerning the current breakdown of contrats solidaires et responsables among the various market operators or concerning the number and proportion of these policies in their portfolios. According to the Commission’s analysis, it nevertheless emerges that mutual societies and unions of mutual societies are legally bound to offer only contrats solidaires [Mutual Society Code, Article L112-1, second subparagraph.]. In practice, it also appears that provident societies are subject to the same obligation. Mutual societies and provident societies should therefore always fulfil the condition of the threshold expressed as a percentage, whereas insurance undertakings with a limited presence in the market for contrats solidaires and wishing to invest in it could have difficulties in meeting the threshold conditions (either in terms of proportion or in absolute terms) and therefore in benefiting from the tax exemptions. This would be the case more specifically for insurance undertakings with a large existing portfolio of ‘traditional’ supplementary health policies which do not meet the conditions for being considered contrats solidaires.