The actual passing on of the exemption from corporation tax to the end consumer is uncertain to say the least. Firstly, the Commission is not in possession of any information enabling it to establish that the corporation tax (and the exemption from such tax) is in fact passed on to individual consumers in the market concerned. Moreover, a recent report by the French Court of Auditors showed the existence of very significant increases in profit margins in the health insurance sector in recent years (from 12 % in 2003 to 23 % in 2007) [Survey on the distribution of funding of sickness expenditure since 1996 and on the transfers made between compulsory sickness insurance, supplementary insurance and households, Court of Auditors, April 2008.]. In this context of a significant increase in profit margins, it can hardly be concluded that a market mechanism exists guaranteeing that the exemption from corporation tax is in fact passed on to end consumers.
125 VIII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › VIII.1. Exemption from corporation tax and local business tax for management operations connected with contrats solidaires et responsables › Analysis of the compatibility of the measure under Article 107(2)(a) TFEU, Decision_act (EU) 2011/319
In force