Despite requests to that effect to the French authorities, the Commission is not in possession of more precise information on the structure of the supplementary health insurance market, such as that relating to groupings of mutual societies, mutual associations, unions of mutual societies and provident societies. Furthermore, despite being requested to do so by the Commission, the French authorities were unable to forward statistics specific to contrats solidaires et responsables (either at aggregate level or at the level of each category of market operator). The statistics in the tables in recitals 102 and 103 therefore refer to the entire supplementary health insurance market, including policies which do not fulfil the conditions of eligibility for the measure notified. A report published by the French Court of Auditors in 2008 [Survey on the distribution of the funding of sickness expenditure since 1996 and on the transfers made between compulsory sickness insurance, supplementary insurance and households, Court of Auditors, April 2008.] stresses the significant statistical deficiencies with regard to supplementary insurance, concerning the number of insured persons, their distribution between the various categories of insurer and the various types of policy (individual policy, optional group policy and compulsory group policy), and the amount of expenditure refunded by category of household and income. On the basis of analyses carried out by the national competition authority, this market nevertheless appears to be fragmented, and even very fragmented, as regards individual policies [See Bulletin officiel de la concurrence, de la consommation et de la répression des fraudes no 7bis of 15 September 2006, p. 2 (publication of the letter from the Minister for the Economy, Finance and Industry of 9 August 2006 to the boards of Mutuelle Préviade-Mutouest, concerning concerted action in the supplementary health insurance sector.], which, however, is only one of the sub-markets concerned by the first measure notified.
101 VIII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › VIII.1. Exemption from corporation tax and local business tax for management operations connected with contrats solidaires et responsables › Description of the supplementary health insurance market in France, Decision_act (EU) 2011/319
In force