10 III. ASSESSMENT, Decision_act (EU) 2008/741

In force

The Communication from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament: Report on progress in creating the internal gas and electricity market [COM(2005) 568 final of 15.11.2005.], hereafter referred to as the ‘2005 Report’ states that ‘many national markets display a high degree of concentration of the industry, impeding the development of effective competition’ [The 2005 Report, p. 2.]. Consequently, it considered that, in respect of electricity generation, ‘one indicator for the degree of competition on national markets is the total market share of the biggest three producers’ [Cf. the 2005 Report, p. 7.]. For 2006, the Polish authorities have indicated a share of the three largest generators of 44,2 % of the attainable power and 52,3 % of the gross production [Cf. point 5.1 of the request.]. In 2007, according to the reply of the Polish authorities received on 28 July, the shares rose to 51,7 % of the attainable power and 58,0 % of the gross production [Cf. page 1 of the reply.]. According to the Polish authorities, the market shares of the three largest operators on the wholesale market amounted to 48,1 % in 2006 and rose to 55,4 % in 2007 [Cf. Point 5.1 of the request and page 2 of the reply.]. It has to be highlighted, that the figures provided by the Polish authorities show a clear growth, between 2006 and 2007, of the market shares of the three largest operators in each field. These levels of concentration are higher than the corresponding percentage, 39, to which Commission Decisions 2006/211/EC [OJ L 76, 15.3.2006, p. 6.] and 2007/141/EC [OJ L 62, 1.3.2007, p. 23.] refer to for the UK. They are similar to (or somewhat higher than) the level (52,2 %) referred to in Commission Decision 2008/585/EC [OJ L 188, 16.7.2008, p. 28.] in respect of Austria and the Polish levels of concentration are finally lower than the corresponding levels referred to in Commission Decisions 2006/422/EC [OJ L 168, 21.6.2006, p. 33.] and 2007/706/EC [OJ L 287, 1.11.2007, p. 18.] concerning, respectively Finland (73,6 %) and Sweden (86,7 %). In all three cases, however, these levels of concentration are ‘offset’ by the ‘competitive pressure on the … market deriving from the potential to import electricity from outside …’ [See, e.g. Recital 12 of Decision 2007/706/EC. Indeed, in the Swedish and Finnish cases, the existence of a regional market has been left open, which, if taken as reference, brought the levels of concentration to 40 %.]. As described under recital 9 above, there are system congestions and limited transfer capacities so that imports amount to less than 3 % of the total Polish generation as compared, e. g., to the Austrian case where ‘imported electricity accounted for approximately a quarter [23,5 % according to information given by the Austrian authorities.] of its total needs [i.e. the quantity of electricity needed for internal consumption and exports.], in particular for base load power’ [See Recital 10 of Decision 2008/585/EC.]. In addition, according to a document issued by the President of the Polish Energy Regulatory Office [The English language version of ‘Roadmap of prices liberalisation for all electricity consumers – Towards the customers rights and effective competition in the power industry sector’, dated February 2008, and published on 30.5.2008 on http://www.ure.gov.pl/portal/en/1/18/Roadmap_of_prices_liberalisation_for_all_electricity_consumers.html, p. 10. In the following, this document will be referred to as ‘Roadmap’.]‘the current structure and the concentration degree of the power industry activity have resulted first from the horizontal and then from vertical consolidation of state-owned power industry companies. The consolidation process, which has negatively affected the competition conditions on the domestic market, will carry on to substantially affect competition development on the wholesale market.’ This level of concentration therefore cannot be taken as an indicator of direct exposure to competition of the generation and wholesale markets.