Another flaw in the study concerns the value of the assets. The study simply takes as the book value of the assets the difference between the item ‘plant and machinery’ in Terni’s 1962 budget (the year before the nationalization) and the same item the following year. Firstly, it should be noted that there is no concrete proof that the difference is attributable exclusively to the loss of the hydro power plant. However, even if, arguendo, that book value could be accepted, the method used in the study would nonetheless be flawed. As confirmed by Italy, the real value of a hydro plant at the moment of an expropriation is linked to the residual duration of the underlying concession [It should be noted that, under Italian law, when hydro-power concessions expire, the hydropower company loses ownership rights on part of its assets, notably certain engineering works, which automatically revert to the State.]. Therefore, the book value of the plant should have been corrected to take this into account. In the study, the book value is simply actualized to 2006 in line with inflation. Therefore, there is evidence suggesting that the study overestimates the assets' value.
90 VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURE › Compensatory nature of the tariff › The ‘study’, Decision_act (EU) 2008/408
In forcesince 20 Nov 2007