61 V. COMMENTS FROM ITALY › Non-aid nature of Terni’s tariff and its clearance under the State aid rules, Decision_act (EU) 2008/408

In forcesince 20 Nov 2007

As regards the policy reasons of the second extension, Italy submits that the tariff is necessary to establish a level-playing field between these energy-intensive companies active in Italy and their competitors in the EU [Notably in France, Germany, Spain, Greece and Finland. Italy has provided a description of schemes allegedly in force in these countries in favour of energy-intensive industries.], which also benefit from reduced energy prices (tariff or contract-based), pending the completion of ongoing infrastructure projects on electricity generation and transport. If the tariff was abolished, the companies in question would delocalize their operations outside the EU. This would inevitably lead to an industrial crisis and sever job losses in the affected regions. Therefore, according to Italy, the prolongation of the tariff should be seen as a transitional solution. Italy quotes the conclusions of the High-level group on competitiveness, energy and environment [First Report of the High Level Group ‘Contributing to an integrated approach on competitiveness, energy and the environment policies — functioning of the energy market, access to energy, energy efficiency and the EU Emission Trading Scheme’ of 2 June 2006.] which suggest, as a long-term solution, the improvement of interconnection and infrastructure, and, as a medium-term solution, long-term supply contracts and partnership between customers and energy suppliers/generators.