82 VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURE › Compensatory nature of the tariff › The ‘study’, Decision_act (EU) 2008/408

In forcesince 20 Nov 2007

As a preliminary remark, the Commission would like to underline that an analysis of the adequacy of the compensatory agreement can only be carried out ex ante, that is, at the time of expropriation. In that context, it should be noted that the mechanism chosen by the Italian authorities aimed to put Società Terni in the same position as if its power plant had not been expropriated, by granting it access to electricity at cost price throughout the duration of its concession. Therefore, the argument that, under this arrangement, the Terni companies may have obtained less that what they were legitimately entitled to is difficult to follow. Besides, the Commission contends that, even if the findings of the study were substantiated (which is not the case, as demonstrated in points (88) to (92), that circumstance would be irrelevant for the purpose of establishing whether the tariff gave the beneficiaries an advantage.