145 VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURE › Compatibility of the aid › The second extension under challenge, Decision_act (EU) 2008/408

In forcesince 20 Nov 2007

The Commission notes that the Court has ruled that ‘the fact that a Member State seeks to approximate, by unilateral measures, conditions of competition in a particular sector of the economy to those prevailing in other Member States cannot deprive the measures in question of their character as State aid’ [See, for example, the judgment of the ECJ in Italian Republic v Commission, Case C-372/97 [2004], ECR I-03679, paragraph 67.]. Further, the Italian argument that such a State aid would be justified by the existence of other (equally distortive) State aids in the EU is to be dismissed altogether. Such an approach would lead to subsidy races and would run counter to the very objective of State aid control. As regards the alleged risk of delocalization outside the EU, the Commission notes that there is no precedent in its decisional practice or in the jurisprudence of the Community courts, where such an argument has been accepted as a justification for the grand of State aids. In the case at issue, there is no need for the Commission to even consider this question since the Italian authorities have not provided any substantiation for such an allegation. Notably, it has not been shown that the tariff was necessary and proportionate to prevent that risk.

  • Judgment of the Court (Sixth Chamber) of 29 April 2004. Italian Republic v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    29 Apr 2004 · 61997CJ0372