79 4. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 4.6. Avoidance of undue distortions of competition, Decision_act (EU) 2007/509

In forcesince 20 Dec 2006

The Commission observes that FSO is active on two markets. Firstly, it competes to obtain licences or orders to produce cars from existing major car manufacturers. In this context, FSO is in competition with existing production plants — either belonging to the major manufacturer concerned or independent — that could also produce these cars and would be interested in assembling them. The Commission observes that over recent years the major car manufacturers active in the EU regularly oblige several plants located in a given geographical area, generally Europe [Producing within the EU to serve the EU market avoids customs duties and limits the transport costs. Therefore large car manufacturers consider the production plants operating within the EU to be more substitutable — and therefore in fiercer competition with each other — than production plants operating both within and outside the EU.], to compete with each other for the production of a given model. Thanks to the aid, FSO can survive and will compete for such production opportunities at the expense of other production plants located in the area. This kind of distortion may have already taken place when FSO was awarded the […] licence agreement by GM DAT. The […] model could theoretically have been produced in another European plant. As FSO will compete for other licence agreements in the future, the Commission can reasonably assume, leaving aside this particular contract, that the kind of distortion just described will take place in the future, at the expense of other plants located in the EU. In this respect, the Commission observes that several plants in the EU currently produce the type of car that FSO plans to produce. Such distortion can seriously harm the production plant which would have got the licence agreement concerned if FSO had left the market. The production of a car model often involves employing hundreds (or even thousands) of persons over several years. The welfare of the Member State where the unsuccessful bidder is located is thereby seriously affected by the presence of FSO on the market.