Besides the measures listed in Table 4, in the decision to open the procedure the Commission expressed doubts that the agreement with public creditors of 22 September 2003 on debt restructuring could contain aid granted before accession. Indeed, the Commission noted that the financial institutions accepted a partial write-off of their claims against FSO only on the condition that the depreciation resulting from this waiver was accepted by the Polish tax authority as a cost reducing taxable income. The Commission therefore indicated that the State may have granted a more substantial concession than the private parties to the agreement. The Polish authorities provided a copy of the agreement of 22 September 2003. The Commission observed that the conversion of debt into FSO shares accepted by the State Treasury was carried out in parallel with and on the same terms as the conversion of debt by DMC, which is a private sector company. In addition, the amount so converted by DMC is much larger than the amount converted by the State Treasury. In these circumstances, the Commission concluded that this operation respected the market economy creditor principle and did not constitute State aid.
56 4. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 4.1. Existence of aid, Decision_act (EU) 2007/509
In forcesince 20 Dec 2006