The analysis that restructuring will be more profitable for creditors than bankruptcy applies even in the best-case scenario of bankruptcy for public creditors. In the best-case bankruptcy scenario for public creditors, only three public institutional creditors in 2005 and one public commercial creditor in 2003 [In fact there are four in 2005, but this is not of relevance in this case as they had already agreed to restructuring in 2003.] could have received a smaller return in the event of restructuring than in the event of bankruptcy. However, all three public institutional creditors have voted against the restructuring and the Polish authorities have guaranteed that their claims will be repaid in full from RFG's assets. Therefore these public creditors have not provided any advantage to the debtor nor have they committed public resources, i.e. their conduct cannot entail any state aid [The Commission is also not concerned by the fact that also other creditors could have rejected the restructuring, as these other creditors had clearly benefited from restructuring and did not want to jeopardise this process.].
116 VI. AID ASSESSMENT › 2. Existence of aid › a) Aid for the restructuring of Huta Częstochowa and application of the private creditor test › Existence of aid as regards debt write-offs in favour of Huta Częstochowa, Decision_act (EU) 2006/937
In forcesince 5 Jul 2005